American essays -- 20th century; Literature -- History and criticism
Modern poets can never praise Greek poetry too much; modern
philosophers, Greek philosophy; modern orators, Greek oratory. But
the shift away from ancient studies as the basis of all education has
tended to leave such employments in the hands of the conservative, or
at least of those whose imaginations live largely on the past, and
has thus contributed to the notion that practical affairs—economy
and polity—are not properly to be studied in Greek literature. To
the extent that knowledge has been multiplied since Aristotle’s
day, this is, of course, true. We cannot look to the Greeks for
information which they did not have, and it would be most un-Greek to
neglect superior sources of knowledge merely on the ground that other
sources were better established in an old tradition. Undoubtedly this
alienation of men of affairs from ancient studies has been due less
to the deficiencies of the Greeks than to the deficiencies of the
teachers of Greek, who, so long holding a vested interest in education
everywhere, permitted themselves, like other vested interests, to fall
into sluggish routine and tyranny, a pitiless round of grammar without
sense and of words without life. The reaction against their monopoly
has been, like most reactions so forced, excessive. In our discovery
that we had overvalued the scanty amount of grammar and prosody
which unwilling students actually carried away from their compulsory
struggles with Greek, with the mere letter of its language without any
deeper spirit or meaning, many have come to undervalue the Greek world
as a laboratory in which, better than anywhere else in history, we may
study human beings vividly and rationally engaged in the conduct of
human life.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account