Here also was a pre-established harmony between educational practice
and psychological theory. Knowledge in the schools was isolated and
made an end in itself. Facts, laws, information have been the staple of
the curriculum. The controversy in educational theory and practice was
between those who relied more upon the sense element in knowledge, upon
contact with things, upon object-lessons, etc., and those who emphasized
abstract ideas, generalizations, etc.—reason, so called, but in reality
other people’s ideas as formulated in books. In neither case was
there any attempt to connect either the sense training or the logical
operations with the problems and interests of the life of practice. Here
again an educational transformation is indicated if we are to suppose
that our psychological theories stand for any truths of life.
The third point of contrast lies in the modern conception of the mind as
essentially a process—a process of growth, not a fixed thing. According
to the older view mind was mind, and that was the whole story. Mind was
the same throughout, because fitted out with the same assortment of
faculties whether in child or adult. If any difference was made it was
simply that some of these ready-made faculties—such as memory—came into
play at an earlier time, while others, such as judging and inferring,
made their appearance only after the child, through memorizing drills,
had been reduced to complete dependence upon the thought of others.
The only important difference that was recognized was one of quantity,
of amount. The boy was a little man and his mind was a little mind—in
everything but the size the same as that of the adult, having its own
ready-furnished equipment of faculties of attention, memory, etc. Now
we believe in the mind as a growing affair, and hence as essentially
changing, presenting distinctive phases of capacity and interest
at different periods. These are all one and the same in the sense
of continuity of life, but all different, in that each has its own
distinctive claims and offices. “First the blade, then the ear, and then
the full corn in the ear.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account