It is important to notice that this *causa vera* would imply vitalistic
causality when taken in the wide meaning which Lamarckism allows to
it: indeed, the power of active adaptation to indefinite changes would
imply a sort of causal connection that is nowhere known except in the
organism. Lamarck himself is not very clear about this point, he seems
to be afraid of certain types of uncritical vitalism in vogue in his
days; but modern writers have most clearly seen what the logical
assumptions of pure Lamarckism are. Next to Cope, August Pauly[146] may
be said to be the most conscious representative of a sort of so-called
psychological vitalism, which indeed Lamarckism as a general and
all-embracing theory must have as its basis.
[146] *Darwinismus und Lamarckismus*, München, 1905.
THE ACTIVE STORING OF CONTINGENT VARIATIONS AS A HYPOTHETIC PRINCIPLE
This point will come out more fully, if now we turn to study a certain
group of principles, upon which dogmatic Lamarckism rests: I say
principles and not facts, for there are no facts but only hypothetic
assumptions in this group of statements. We do know a little about
adaptations, at least to a certain extent, and it was only about the
sphere of the validity of a law, which was known to be at work in
certain cases, that hypothetical additions were made. In the second
group of the foundations of Lamarckism we know absolutely nothing;
accidental variations of form are supposed to occur, and the organism is
said to possess the faculty of keeping and storing these variations and
of handing them down to the next generation, if they happen to satisfy
any of its needs.
But these needs are not of the actual type, brought forth by a change of
the functional state of the individual, as in the case of adaptations:
they are of a somewhat mysterious nature. A glance at the theory of the
origin of the movements which are called acts of volition in the human
child may serve to elucidate what is meant.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account