“Referring to your assertion in March that truth is absolute,” he said,
“is not truth itself relative on this plane? Truth as a statement of
eternal law is absolute, but when applied to concrete facts and ideas, it
changes from time to time? That is, a concrete statement which expressed
the relations of certain mundane conditions to the eternal verities in
B.C. 1000, would not necessarily be a correct statement of the relations
of corresponding conditions to those verities in the year 1900 A.D.”
“That is the idea on which this whole revelation is based,” she returned.
“These things have always been true. They would not have sounded true in
the year one, any more than a lot of the ‘truths’ of that day are true
now.”
A night or two after this, he said he would like more light on the
practical application of these principles, especially those in relation
to freedom. “How, for instance, would you go about helping a school?” he
asked. “Take, as concrete examples, a University like ——, its Faculty
held in subjection by hidebound trustees, and the proposed People’s
University, to be governed from day to day by plebiscite or referendum,
with no defined policy for procedure beyond a general idea of freedom.
‘You may lead a horse to water, but you can’t make him drink.’ Should
the construction of the trough be left to chance, or should it be planned
carefully? In other words, should mundane provision and prevision be
employed in building it?”
“It has been said already that men must first learn to think, and
to govern themselves, before they can be free.” It was Mary K. who
answered. “If experience were not taken into consideration, progress
would be impossible. Mundane prevision and provision is essential to all
constructive activity on your plane. Opinions will differ as to ways and
means of applying principles of progress. The first way to help a school
is to establish unity among the teachers. Not only unity of purpose, but
a certain large unity of method, that one may not tear down what his
brother builds. Ideals of freedom have been confused by men resenting
the first law of freedom—discipline. Lack of discipline, carried to its
logical conclusion, would return the world to chaos. The school that is
free in its teaching must be carried on by disciplined teachers, united
in a purpose of progress clearly recognized and agreed upon, to teach
discipline that the minds of men may dare to be free.”
“The idea underlying that, I take it, is that as the athlete whose body
is thoroughly trained and co-ordinated dares to jump an abyss, without
fear of falling, so the man whose mind and spirit are disciplined can
jump an intellectual abyss, without losing balance or sanity.”
“Yes. And as a man trained to carry great weights on his shoulders must
be trained to it from youth, so the man who would carry government and
freedom of thought must train his mind to carry its weight—not alone to
hold it briefly, but to carry it on.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account