The sexagenarian; or, the recollections of a literary life (Volume 2 of 2)Beloe, William
General
The sexagenarian; or, the recollections of a literary life (Volume 2 of 2)
Beloe, William
Authors, English; Beloe, William, 1756-1817; English literature -- Anecdotes
“In thus examining the present Edition of Lucretius, we feel a strong
confidence that we shall not be suspected of being actuated by any
resentment against a person, who must himself feel the chief evils of
a restless, impatient, intolerant, mind. We think it, indeed, most
lamentable, that a man, whose proper occupations are study and polite
literature, should be so little able to command himself, as to fall into
extravagances of political conduct, injurious ultimately to himself and
family. Too many instances of this spirit appear completely out of their
places in this Edition of Lucretius, in the form of political verses,
allusions to the glories of France, and aspirations after similar changes
here, with prophetic intimations of their approach.
“In such a farrago, abuse of us and our work, as supporting all that
Mr. W. wishes to see overthrown, is virtually the highest compliment,
and though we owe no gratitude to the author, we cannot but approve the
tendency of his conduct towards us.
“We see, however, in his pages not the slightest tincture of that
character, which he has, very early in his Preface, bestowed
upon himself. ‘Si quis unquam diffidens mei.’ A most extravagant
self-confidence, on the contrary, is every where conspicuous, except in
a few of the prefatory flourishes; and though his maturer judgment has
enabled him to see in his own ‘Silva critica plurima quæ sint juveniliter
temeraria απροσδιονυσα prorsus et homine critico indigna,’ yet the very
same character unimproved, will be found to prevail in his critical
conjectures, scattered abundantly throughout the notes to his work, and
readily accessible by means of his critical index. No author escapes his
rage for correction, and Horace and Virgil in particular would have as
little knowledge of their own works, were they presented to them reformed
à la Wakefield, as we should of the British constitution were it given
to his emendation. We can, however, pity while we censure, and most
sincerely wish that with a more temperate mind, even in literature, he
would give himself exclusively, and without mixture, to those studies,
in which, with all his failings, he has certainly made a proficiency not
common among scholars of this country.”
Whether the miscellaneous articles which follow be worthy of insertion,
may by some be doubted, but they are genuine, and asperity may be
softened by the consideration that they are the last.
If the reader will refer to the edition of Demosthenes, by Wolfius,
printed at Frankfort, 1604, at p. 470, he will find the Oration of
Æschines contre Ctesiphontem to conclude thus:
Και ειμεν καλως και αζιως του αδικηματος κατηγορηκα, ειπον ως
εβουλομην, ειδε ενδεεστερως ως εδυναμην.
Porson has noted a singular coincidence of expression to be found in the
38th verse of the last chapter of the second book of Maccabees.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account