The Silver Domino; Or, Side Whispers, Social and LiteraryCorelli, Marie
General
The Silver Domino; Or, Side Whispers, Social and Literary
Corelli, Marie
English essays -- 19th century; Literature -- Criticism and interpretation; Satire
Swinburne, like Tennyson, manifests a great abhorrence for the
society of his fellow-creatures, but his shrinking churlishness is
more accountable to the world than that of the elder bard. Tennyson's
muse is pure, refined, and ever persuasive to good; while at times
Swinburne seems possessed of a very devil of lewdness and atheism; and
lewdness and atheism are not yet openly accepted as desirable parts
of a liberal education. Of his former rank and rampant republicanism
nothing need be said; the politics of a poet are always the most absurd
and shifty part of him. And though lewdness of the pen is beginning
to be more tolerated than once it was, thanks to the importation of
such foreign trash as the "Kreutzer Sonata" and other publications of
a like free-and-easy pruriency, the love of moral filth is not yet
universal. We are dabbling in mire, but we do not willingly wallow in
it--at least, not at present. The honest British guffaw of laughter
that greets crazy old Ibsen's contemptible delineations of women,
has a jovial wholesome music in it which the caterwauling of cliques
cannot silence. And there is a strong under-current of feeling in
the peoples of nearly all countries, that whatever prose-writers may
choose to do by way of degrading themselves and their profession, poets
should draw the line somewhere. Poor paralytic old Mrs. Grundy still
pretends, in the most ridiculously senile way, to be quite shocked at
the idea of reading "Don Juan," when, as a matter of fact, she has put
on strong spectacles over her blear eyes in order to gloat upon far
worse literary provender. There is not a line that Byron ever wrote
approaching to the revolting indecency of Swinburne's "Faustine"--a
most disgusting set of bad verses, let me tell Algernon, with my
frankest compliments. The only excuse that can be offered for such
a sickening affront to the very name of poetry, is that the writer
must have been suffering at the time he wrote it from a sort of moral
disease.
From moral disease no moral health can come--and in spite of
Swinburne's unquestioned and unquestionable genius, I believe his fame
will perish as utterly and hopelessly as a brilliant torch plunged
suddenly in the sea. There is no stamina in him--nothing to hold or
to keep in all this meteor-like shower of words upon words, thoughts
upon thoughts, similes upon similes; there lacks steadiness in the
music; none of the vast eternal underthrobbings of nature give truth or
grandeur to the strain. It is the harsh raving and shrill chanting of a
man in fever and delirium; not the rich pulsing rhythm of a singer in
noble accord with life, love, and labour.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account