The Southern Case for School SegregationKilpatrick, James Jackson
History
The Southern Case for School Segregation
Kilpatrick, James Jackson
African Americans -- Segregation; Segregation -- Southern States
Dr. McGurk’s analysis of the professional literature in this field
closely parallels Dr. Shuey’s report. Between 1935 and 1950, he has
stated, sixty-three articles appeared in professional journals of
psychology dealing with Negro-white test-score differences. _In all
sixty-three of them_, the average test score of the Negro subjects
was found to be lower than the average test score of the white
subjects with whom they were compared. Six of these investigations
are regarded by McGurk as especially significant:
1. A study of a group of Canadian Negroes and whites in 1939 by H.
A. Tanser. The Negro children tested were the descendants of slaves
who had escaped from the South prior to and during the Civil War.
Their social and economic opportunities had been generally equal
to those of whites in the area. Yet the findings of three standard
psychological tests administered to children in grades 1-8 found the
Negro averages far below the white averages at every age and every
grade. For the total groups, only 13 to 20 per cent of the Negroes
overlapped the white average, and in no case did the overlap exceed
20 per cent.
2. A study of white and Negro children in a poor section of rural
Virginia, done by M. Bruce in 1940. In order to eliminate the factor
of social and economic differences, the author first administered a
test of socio-economic status, and then paired off her subjects so
that each member of a pair, one Negro child and one white child, had
the same socio-economic score. Negro overlapping on three separate
tests ranged between 15 per cent and 20 per cent.
3. A study by Dr. Shuey of white and Negro college students in
New York, in 1942. Again, the Negro and white students were first
given socio-economic tests in order to pair them off. The Negro
overlap amounted to 18 per cent. Of this investigation, Dr. McGurk
says: “Considering that this was a highly selected group of college
students, such low overlapping is surprising. It does not lend
credence to the belief that socio-economic factors are responsible
for the Negro-white differences in psychological test performance.”
4. A study of white and Negro kindergarten children in Minneapolis,
1944, done by F. Brown. The test scores found a 31 per cent
overlapping. (At very early ages, overlap always is greater because
tests deal more with performance and with sensory-motor responses,
and less with verbal skills).
5. A study by T. F. Rhoads and associates of white and Negro children
at the age of three. This was a very detailed study, in which each
of the subjects was clinically examined from birth until the time he
was administered a psychological test. Socio-economic factors were
reported to be generally equal for the entire group of subjects. The
overlapping amounted to 30 per cent.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account