The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 1, December, 1835Various
General
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 1, December, 1835
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
We feel it almost an act of supererogation to speak of this book,
which is long since in the hands of every American who has leisure for
reading at all. The matter itself is deeply interesting, but, as
usual, its chief beauty is beauty of style. The Conquest of Spain by
the Saracens, an event momentous in the extreme, is yet enveloped, as
regards the motives and actions of the principal _dramatis personæ_ in
triple doubt and confusion. To snatch from this uncertainty a few
striking and picturesque legends, possessing, at the same time, some
absolute portion of verity, and to adorn them in his own magical
language is all that Mr. Irving has done in the present instance. But
that he has done this little well it is needless to say. He does not
claim for the Legends the authenticity of history properly so
called,--yet all are partially _facts_, and however extravagant {65}
some may appear, they will all, to use the words of the author
himself, "be found in the works of sage and reverend chroniclers of
yore, growing side by side with long acknowledged truths, and might be
supported by learned and imposing references in the margin." Were we
to instance any one of the narratives as more beautiful than the rest,
it would be _The Story of the Marvellous and Portentous Tower_.
GODWIN'S NECROMANCY.
_Lives of the Necromancers: or an Account of the Most Eminent Persons
in Successive Ages, who have claimed for themselves, or to whom has
been imputed by others, the Exercise of Magical Power. By William
Godwin, Author of "Caleb Williams," &c. New York: Published by Harper
& Brothers._
The name of the author of Caleb Williams, and of St. Leon, is, with
us, a word of weight, and one which we consider a guarantee for the
excellence of any composition to which it may be affixed. There is
about all the writings of Godwin, one peculiarity which we are not
sure that we have ever seen pointed out for observation, but which,
nevertheless, is his chief idiosyncrasy--setting him peculiarly apart
from all other _literati_ of the day. We allude to an air of mature
thought--of deliberate premeditation pervading, in a remarkable
degree, even his most common-place observations. He never uses a
hurried expression, or hazards either an ambiguous phrase, or a
premature opinion. His style therefore is highly artificial; but the
extreme finish and proportion always observable about it, render this
artificiality, which in less able hands would be wearisome, in him a
grace inestimable. We are never tired of his terse, nervous, and
sonorous periods--for their terseness, their energy, and even their
melody, are made, in all cases, subservient to the sense with which
they are invariably fraught. No English writer, with whom we have any
acquaintance, with the single exception of Coleridge, has a fuller
appreciation of the value of _words_; and none is more nicely
discriminative between closely-approximating meanings.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account