The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 10, September, 1836Various
General
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 10, September, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
But the speaker is now seated; Lord Brougham has leapt from his seat;
he is on his feet; he has regained the floor; he retains it, and will
not easily part with it; he has declared that he has but two words to
say; if you have any business to attend to, go about it; at the end of
two hours you may return, you will find him in the midst of his
argument. It is much to be regretted that long experience of the bar
and the parliament have not moderated a mind of this temper. He has
just uttered a most cutting sarcasm—observe how he dulls its effect by
reiterating and expanding it. He has perfectly established the
impregnable strength of an argument; he proceeds to overthrow it
himself, that he may build up others upon its ruins; it is thus his
indiscretion injures the best cause and deforms his ablest discourses.
Like an imprudent æronaut, he bursts his balloon and falls with it to
the earth, in consequence of having filled it too full. We who are
hearers, like well enough to be convinced by an argument, or to smile
at a piece of irony; but we can comprehend an allusion. We are
mortified at having every thing explained so elaborately. The more you
persist in it, the more weary we become. Your obstinacy in doubting
our intelligence—wounds and vexes us.
This excess of pedantry is the principal defect in the oratory of Lord
Brougham. He has been well called the school-master. I do not deny his
extraordinary gifts as a learned debater, always caustic and
indefatigable; but these extravagant discourses are out of all
proportion, above all in the House of Lords, which treats all
questions in a summary way, and in some degree after the fashion of
the drawing room. It is a great want of tact not to suit oneself to
one's audience. The manner of Henry Brougham was much more suitable to
the House of Commons, where discussions are more full, and where one
is less prepared to come to an early conclusion; he still retains the
lawyer. He has never been able to throw off the violent and comic
gestures of the gown, storming and thundering, in reciting a date or a
section of a law. Without doubt his harangues fatigue him as much as
they do those who listen to him; he does not spare himself, bawling
and gesticulating without any regard to his own person; he bends and
twists himself like a posture master; he dances and leaps with his
words; he perspires and grows heated, but he leaves the hearer cold;
his is not the eloquence which inflames the blood.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account