The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 11, October, 1836Various
History
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 11, October, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
Yes, she was one of those—the few—
That decorate the earth;
A diamond of the purest dew;
Nor knew I half its worth {702}
Till death had stolen the precious gem
That would have graced a diadem.
But why am I lamenting here,
When she is now at rest;
And, happy in her heavenly sphere,
Her soul is with the blest?
No, no, I will not, will not weep:
Enjoy, sweet saint, thy sacred sleep.
* *
_Norfolk_.
ALFIERI AND SCHILLER.
BY MRS. E. F. ELLET.
The characteristic differences between the national drama of the
Germans and that of the Italians, as well as in the genius of the two
writers, are strikingly shown by a comparison of the works of Alfieri
and Schiller. Nor need we refer to the whole range of their respective
productions; the two great poets have more than once, by their choice
of the same subject for dramatic effort, afforded us opportunity to
draw a parallel between them. The distinction is exactly the reverse
of what the characters of the nations would lead us to expect; the
cold and classic simplicity of the ancient school pertaining to the
more ardent and volatile Italian, while the energy of expression and
warmth of action peculiar to the romantic system belong to the
representative of a colder and more meditative race. We shall not now
employ ourselves in endeavoring to discover the causes of the general
barrenness of the drama among a people of a temperament so
imaginative, and whose history has been so rich in the materials of
fiction. It is our object to show the vast difference which actually
exists between the tragic compositions of Italy and those of the
German school; as well as to give some idea of the peculiarities of
the two authors who form the subject of this article. For this
purpose, we select a play of each, founded upon the same historical
event, and portraying in part the same characters; and purpose to
offer a close analysis of both.
The “_Filippo_” of Alfieri treats of the same events with the “_Don
Carlos_” of Schiller. It was the first published production of the
noble poet, and is marked by much of the harshness of diction and
severe simplicity, amounting almost to baldness, which distinguished
his earlier plays. The author avoids, with scrupulous care, any thing
approaching to local coloring; excluding all inferior personages from
the stage, and admitting no forms or observances that might remind us
of our vicinity to the person of the Spanish monarch. The chief care
of Alfieri is ever bestowed upon the character of his protagonist; and
it is to that point we must direct our attention.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account