The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 2, January, 1836Various
General
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 2, January, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
Now, in this, all the actual burlesque consists in {118} merely
substituting things for words. There are many of our readers who will
recognize in this imaginary interview between Mr. Yeadon and Mr.
Simms, at least a family likeness to the written Dedication of the
latter. This Dedication is, nevertheless, quite as good as one half
the antique and lackadaisical courtesies with which we daily see the
initial leaves of our best publications disfigured.
"The Partisan," as we are informed by Mr. Simms in his Advertisement,
(Preface?) was originally contemplated as one novel of a series to be
devoted to our war of Independence. "With this object," says the
author, "I laid the foundation more broadly and deeply than I should
have done, had I purposed merely the single work. Several of the
persons employed were destined to be the property of the series--that
part of it at least which belonged to the locality. Three of these
works were to have been devoted to South Carolina, and to comprise
three distinct periods of the war of the Revolution in that State.
One, and the first of these, is the story now submitted to the reader.
I know not that I shall complete, or even continue the series." Upon
the whole we think that he had better not.
There is very little plot or connexion in the book before us; and Mr.
Simms has evidently aimed at neither. Indeed we hardly know what to
think of the work at all. Perhaps, with some hesitation, we may call
it an historical novel. The narrative begins in South Carolina, during
the summer of 1780, and comprises the leading events of the Revolution
from the fall of Charleston, to the close of that year. We have the
author's own words for it that his object has been principally to give
a fair picture of the province--its condition, resources, and
prospects--during the struggle between Gates and Cornwallis, and the
period immediately subsequent to the close of the campaign in the
defeat of the Southern defending army. Mr. S. assures us that the
histories of the time have been continually before him in the
prosecution of this object, and that, where written records were found
wanting, their places have been supplied by local chronicles and
tradition. Whether the idea ever entered the mind of Mr. Simms that
his very laudable design, as here detailed, might have been better
carried into effect by a work of a character _purely_ historical, we,
of course, have no opportunity of deciding. To ourselves, every
succeeding page of "The Partisan" rendered the supposition more
plausible. The interweaving fact with fiction is at all times
hazardous, and presupposes on the part of general readers that degree
of intimate acquaintance with fact which should never be presupposed.
In the present instance, the author has failed, so we think, in
confining either his truth or his fable within its legitimate,
individual domain. Nor do we at all wonder at his failure in
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account