The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 2, January, 1836Various
General
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 2, January, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
Some two or three paragraphs above we made use of these expressions.
"The history of the march of Gates' army, his fool-hardiness, &c. are
as well told as any details of a like nature can be told in language
exceedingly confused, ill-arranged, and ungrammatical." Mr. Simms'
English is bad--shockingly bad. This is no mere assertion on our
parts--we proceed to prove it. "Guilt," says our author, (see page 98,
vol. i.) "must always _despair its charm_ in the presence of the true
avenger"--what is the meaning of this sentence?--after much reflection
we are unable to determine. At page 115, vol. i, we have these words.
"He was under the guidance of an elderly, drinking sort of person--one
of the fat, beefy class, whose worship of the belly-god has given an
unhappy distension to that ambitious, though most erring member." By
the 'most erring member' Mr. S. means to say _the belly_--but the
sentence implies the _belly-god_. Again, at page 126, vol. i. "It was
for the purpose of imparting to Col. Walton the contents of that not
yet notorious proclamation of Sir Henry Clinton, with which he
demanded the performance of military duty from the persons who had
been paroled; and by means of which, on departing from the province,
he planted the seeds of that _revolting_ patriotism which {120}
finally overthrew his authority." It is unnecessary to comment on the
unauthorized use here, of the word 'revolting.' In the very next
sentence we see the following. "Colonel Walton received his guests
with his accustomed urbanity: _he received them alone_." This language
implies that Colonel Walton received those particular guests and no
others, and should be read with an emphasis on the word '_them_'--but
Mr. Simms' meaning is very different. He wishes to say that Col.
Walton was alone when his guests were ushered into his presence. At
page 136, vol. i, the hero, Singleton, concludes a soliloquy with the
ungrammatical phrase, "And yet none love her like me!" At page 143,
vol. i, we read--"'That need not surprise you, Miss Walton; you
remember that ours are British soldiers'--smiling, and with a bow was
the response of the Colonel." We have no great difficulty herein
_guessing_ what Mr. Simms wishes to say--his actual words convey no
meaning whatever. The present participle 'smiling' has no substantive
to keep it company; and the 'bow,' as far as regards its syntactical
disposition, may be referred with equal plausibility to the Colonel,
to Miss Walton, to the British soldiers, or to the author of "The
Partisan." At page 147, vol. i, we are told--"She breathed more freely
released from his embrace, and he then gazed upon her with a _painful
sort of pleasure_, her look was so clear, so dazzling, so spiritual,
so _unnaturally life-like_." The attempt at paradox has here led Mr.
Simms into error. The _painful sort of pleasure_ we may suffer to
pass; but _life_ is the most natural thing in the world, and to call
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account