The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 2, January, 1836Various
General
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 2, January, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
In the sentence beginning, "I have said it may be the spirit of the
times, for we see signs of it, alas, in Old England, _but there must
be something_," _&c._ Mr. Latrobe has involved himself in a
contradiction. By the words, "but there must be something in the
political atmosphere of America which is more than ordinarily
congenial to" _insubordination_, he implies (although unintentionally)
that our natural impulses lead us in this direction--and that these
natural impulses are permitted by God, we, at all events, are not
permitted to doubt. In the words immediately succeeding those just
quoted, he maintains (what is very true) that "_subordination_ was
both permitted by God in the natural impulses of the human mind, and
ordered in His word." The question thus resolves itself into a matter
of _then_ and _now_--of times past and times present--of the days of
the patriarchs and of the days of widely disseminated knowledge. The
infallibility of the instinct of those natural impulses which led men
to obey in the infancy {122} of all things, we have no intention of
denying--we must demand the same grace for those natural impulses
which prompt men to govern themselves in the senectitude of the world.
In the sentence, "Who shall say but that if these bonds are distorted
and set aside, the first and the greatest--which binds us in
subjection to the law of God--will not also be weakened, if not
broken?" the sophistry is evident; and we have only a few words to say
in reply. In the first place, the writer has assumed that those bonds
are "_distorted_" and "_set aside_" which are merely slackened to an
endurable degree. In the second place, the "setting aside" these
bonds, (granting them to be set aside) so far from tending to weaken
our subjection to the law of God, will the more readily confirm that
subjection, inasmuch as our responsibilities to man have been denied,
through the conviction of our responsibilities to God, and--to God
alone.
We recommend "The Rambler" to the earnest attention of our readers. It
is the best work on America yet published. Mr. Latrobe is a scholar, a
man of intellect and a gentleman.
THE SOUTH-WEST.
_The South-West. By a Yankee. New York: Published by Harper and
Brothers._
This work, from the pen of Professor Ingraham, rivals the book of
which we have just been speaking, in degree--although not in
quality--of interest. Mr. Latrobe has proved himself a man of the
world, an able teacher, and a philosopher. Professor Ingraham is an
amusing traveller, full of fun, gossip, and shrewd remark. In all that
relates to the "Mechanics of book-writing," the Englishman is
immeasurably the superior.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account