The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 5, April, 1836 — John Shaqi
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 5, April, 1836Various
General
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 5, April, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
From the Charlottesville Advocate.
_The Southern Literary Messenger_.--We have been favored by Mr.
White, the proprietor, with the March No. of this periodical. The
delay in the publication has been occasioned by the desire of Mr.
White to insert Prof. Dew's Address. However desirable a regular and
punctual issue may be, we are disposed to excuse the delay on the
present occasion, for the reason assigned.
As the Messenger has now passed through the difficulties attendant
on new enterprises, is on a permanent footing, and has vindicated
its claims to rank among the first of American Periodicals, we
commenced the perusal of the present number, predetermined to
censure whenever we could get the slightest pretext. We have read it
calmly and with a "critic's eye," and though it is not faultless,
for with two exceptions the poetry is below mediocrity, we have been
so delighted with most of the articles, as not to have the heart to
censure. We candidly regard it the best single number of any
American periodical we have ever seen. Mr. Dew's Address and Mr.
Stanton's Essay on Manual Labor Schools, are articles of enduring
and inestimable worth.
We subjoin the following notice of the contents from the Richmond
Compiler, with which we in the main concur.
From the Richmond Compiler.
We have already announced the appearance of the Literary Messenger
for March 1836. We always read the work with pleasure, and have
frequently awarded to it the high praise it so well deserves. In the
present instance, we are forcible struck with a sort of merit so
rare in publications of the kind, that, to a certain class of
readers, our praise may sound like censure.
We hazard nothing in saying, that in the pages before us, there is
more substantial matter, more information, more food for the mind,
and more provocative to thought, than we have ever seen in any
periodical of a miscellaneous character. A chapter from Lionel
Granby--a _jeu d'esprit_ from Mr. Poe--some of the reviews--and a
page or two of description--together with a very few metrical
lines--make the sum total of light reading.
We would not be understood to mean that the rest is heavy. Far from
it. But we want some word to distinguish that which ought to be read
and studied, from that which may be read for amusement only. He who
shall read the rest of the number, must be very careless or very
dull, if he is not edified and instructed. We will add, that his
taste must be bad, if he is not tempted to receive the instruction
here offered by the graces of style, the originality of thought, and
the felicity of illustration, with which the gravest of these
articles abounds.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account