The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 5, April, 1836Various
General
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 5, April, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
_Southern Literary Messenger_.--We have received the last number of
this beautiful and valuable Magazine, and take great pleasure in
expressing the delight with which we have perused its contents. It
is certainly the best Magazine now published in the Union, and is an
honor to Southern literature and talent. The present number like its
predecessors, is replete with 'pearls, and gems, and flowers,' and
fully sustains the elevated character of the work. The Critical
Notices are peculiarly meritorious and sensible. The Messenger is
now under the editorial guidance of Edgar A. Poe, a gentleman highly
distinguished for his literary taste and talent.
From the Fincastle Democrat.
_Southern Literary Messenger_.--We have been furnished, by the
worthy publisher, with the February number of this "best of American
periodicals," as it is said to be by a distinguished Northern
contemporary. This number is pronounced, in all of the many notices
which we have seen, to be the best of the fifteen that have been
published; of this we are not competent to decide, not having been
favored with the previous numbers; but, be it as it may, we
cheerfully coincide in the annexed sentiment of the editor of the
Pennsylvanian:--"If it is not well supported by our brethren of the
South, no faith is to be placed in their sectional feeling; _it is
vox et præterea nihil_."
From the U. S. Gazette.
The Southern Literary Messenger for March, full of good matter, is
at hand--delayed with a view of giving the whole of Professor Dew's
address. We miss the racy and condemnatory criticism that
distinguishes the work, and which has been favorable to the
production of good books. We who publish no volumes, look with
complacency upon severe criticism.
From the Richmond Compiler.
The writer of the following judicious article, has performed a task
for which he is entitled to our thanks. A want of time and a lack of
the proper talent for criticism, have prevented us from giving our
opinion at length upon the last number of the Messenger; and this
sketch saves us the labor. We accord with most of the writer's
positions, and are pleased with the good sense, moderation and
delicacy with which he has discharged the office of censor.
Criticism, to be useful, must be just and impartial. This is both.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account