The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 6, May, 1836Various
General
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 6, May, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
Some three months since we had occasion to express our high admiration
of Lieutenant Slidell's _American in England_. The work now before us
presents to the eye of the critical reader many if not all of those
peculiarities which distinguished its predecessor. We find the same
force and freedom. We recognize the same artist-like way of depicting
persons, scenery, or manners, by a succession of minute and
well-managed details. We perceive also the same terseness and
originality of expression. Still we must be pardoned for saying that
many of the same _niaiseries_ are also apparent, and most especially
an abundance of very bad grammar and a superabundance of gross errors
in syntatical arrangement.
With the _Dedicatory Letter_ prefixed to _Spain Revisited_, we have no
patience whatever. It does great credit to the kind and gentlemanly
feelings of Lieutenant Slidell, but it forms no inconsiderable
drawback upon {390} our previously entertained opinions of his good
taste. We can at no time, and under no circumstances, see either
meaning or delicacy in parading the sacred relations of personal
friendship before the unscrupulous eyes of the public. And even when
these things are well done and briefly done, we do believe them to be
in the estimation of all persons of nice feeling a nuisance and an
abomination. But it very rarely happens that the closest scrutiny can
discover in the least offensive of these dedications any thing better
than extravagance, affectation or incongruity. We are not sure that it
would be impossible, in the present instance, to designate gross
examples of all three. What connection has the name of Lieutenant
Upshur with the present Spanish Adventures of Lieutenant Slidell?
None. Then why insist upon a connection which the world cannot
perceive? The Dedicatory letter, in the present instance, is either a
_bona fide_ epistle actually addressed before publication to
Lieutenant Upshur, intended strictly as a memorial of friendship, and
published because no good reasons could be found for the
non-publication--or its plentiful professions are all hollowness and
falsity, and it was never meant to be any thing more than a very
customary public compliment.
Our first supposition is negatived by the stiff and highly constrained
character of the _style_, totally distinct from the usual, and we will
suppose the less carefully arranged composition of the author. What
man in his senses ever wrote as follows, from the simple impulses of
gratitude or friendship?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account