The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 8, July, 1836Various
General
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 8, July, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
This work will form an æra in the reading annals of the more
contemplative portion of Americans—while its peculiar merits will be
overlooked by the multitude. The broad and solid basis of its
superstructure—the scrupulous accuracy of its _data_—the disdain of
mere _logic_ in its deductions—the _generalizing_, calm,
comprehensive—in a word, the _German_ character of its philosophy,
will insure it an enthusiastic welcome among all the nobler spirits of
our land. What though its general tenor be opposed at least apparently
to many of our long cherished opinions and deeply-rooted prejudices?
Shall we less welcome the truth, or glory in its advancement because
of its laying bare our own individual errors? But the England of Von
Raumer will be sadly and wickedly misconceived if it be really
conceived as militating against a Republicanism _here_, which it
opposes with absolute justice, in Great Britain, and Prussia. It will
be sadly misconceived if it be regarded as embracing one single
sentence with which the most bigoted lover of abstract Democracy can
have occasion to find fault. At the same time we cannot help believing
that it will, _in some measure_, be effectual in diverting the minds
of our countrymen, and of all who read it, from that perpetual and
unhealthy excitement about the forms and machinery of governmental
action which have within the last half century so absorbed their
attention as to exclude in a strange degree all care of the proper
_results_ of good government—the happiness of a people—improvement in
the condition of mankind—practicable under a thousand forms—and
without which all forms are valueless and shadowy phantoms. It will
serve also as an auxiliary in convincing mankind that the origin of
the principal social evils of any given land are _not_ to be found
(except in a much less degree than we usually suppose) either in
republicanism or monarchy or any especial method of government—that we
must look for the source of our greatest defects in a variety of
causes totally distinct from any such action—in a love of gain, for
example, whose direct tendency to social evil was vividly shown in an
essay on _American Social Elevation_ lately published in the
“Messenger.” In a word, let this book of Von Raumer's be read with
attention, as a study, and _as a whole_. If this thing be done—which
is but too seldom done (here at least) in regard to works of a like
character and cast—and we will answer for the result—as far as that
result depends upon the deliberate and unprejudiced declaration of any
well-educated man. We agree cordially with the opinion expressed by
Mrs. Austin in her Preface to this American imprint. The book is the
most valuable addition to our stock of knowledge about England and her
institutions which America has ever received or which, in the ordinary
course of things she is likely to receive.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account