The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 8, July, 1836Various
General
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 8, July, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
These schools (the German and Italian) were, it is true, internally
impelled by Christianity towards the noblest goal of humanity and of
art, but they have unsuitably introduced the doctrine of election even
into these regions. To the beautiful forms pardoned by God are opposed
the ugly bodies of the non-elect; to the healthy, the sick; to the
blessed, the damned. In theology, in philosophy, in history, this dark
side of existence may be employed at pleasure, but when it appears in
art I feel hurt and uncomfortable.... This _caput mortuum_ may be
wholly separated. It should evaporate and become invisible. Not till
this is accomplished can we place Christian art above Greek art, as
the Christian religion above the Greek religion. A great confusion of
ideas still prevails, in considering and judging of these things. How
often have modern works of art been praised in reference to the
doctrine, and ancient works reprobated for similar reasons. But the
demoniac is not a suitable subject for art, merely because he is
mentioned in the Bible; or a Venus to be rejected, because the worship
of the goddess has ceased.... Music without discord is unmeaning and
tedious, and painting and sculpture likewise need such discord. But
every musical discord is necessarily resolved, according to the rules
of art—while painters and sculptors often leave their dissonances
unresolved, and eternized in stone. In every discord I feel its
transition into euphony. It is but a motion, a creation of harmony;
but no musician would ever think of affirming that to sing out of tune
is ever permitted, much less that it is necessary in his art. The
combats of the Centaurs and Lapithæ display a chain of discords, which
originate, advance, and develop themselves—one could set them to music
without violating the rules and euphony of the science. But were we to
attempt a similar musical transposition with many celebrated statues,
we should break all the strings of the instrument by the violence of
the effort.
We had noted many other passages for comment and extract—(especially a
lively Philippic against Utilitarianism on pages 398, 399, an account
of Bentham's penitentiary, and other matters) but we perceive that we
are already infringing upon our limits. This book about England will
and must be read, and will as certainly be relished, by a numerous
class, although not by a majority, of our fellow-citizens. The author,
we rejoice to hear, has engaged to translate into his own language the
Washington Papers of Mr. Sparks. We will only add that Professor Von
Raumer has the honor of being called by the English organ of the High
Church and Ultra Tory Party, “a vagrant blackguard unfit for the
company of a decent servants' hall.”
MEMOIRS OF AN AMERICAN LADY.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account