The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 8, July, 1836Various
General
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 8, July, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
Poe, and to ourselves.
The present number, we do not think equal as a whole to the March
number, and still less to that for February—which latter may be safely
placed in comparison with any single number of any Journal in
existence for the great vigor, profundity, and originality of its
articles. Yet we do not mean to say that the number now before us is
not an admirable one, and fully equal to any of our Northern magazines
in its communications, while it far surpasses the best of them in its
Editorial department.
The first article is “MSS. of Benj. Franklin,” printed from MSS. in
the hand-writing of Franklin himself, and never published in any
edition of his works. It is unnecessary to say more than this to call
public attention to so valuable a paper. “Lionel Granby,” chap. X. is
the next prose article. We like this chapter as well if not better,
than any of the former ones. The writer of these papers is evidently a
man of genius—we might perhaps express our meaning more fully by
saying that he has that degree of genius which enables him to
appreciate, and keenly feel the labors of men of genius. Some of his
detached passages may be considered as very fine. He has, however, no
capacity to sustain a connected narrative of any length, and these
chapters of “Lionel Granby” are consequently replete with the most
ludicrous incongruities. They evince great ignorance of what is called
the world. They are full of a shallow pedantry. Their style is
excessively turgid, ungrammatical, and _inconsequential_. “The
Prairie” is a delightful little sketch of real scenery. “Random
Thoughts” is an excellent article, evincing much true learning and
acumen. Such contributors as the author of this paper are invaluable
to the _Messenger_. “Odds and Ends” is from the pen of Oliver
Oldschool—a former correspondent of the Messenger. We believe Oliver
Oldschool to be Mr. Garnett, the author of many excellent things on
Female Education. His present essay is exceedingly amusing—but
somewhat old fashioned. “The Hall of Incholese” by J. N. McJilton
should not have been admitted into the columns of the Messenger. It is
an imitation of the Editor's tale of Bon-Bon, and like most other
imitations, utterly unworthy of being mentioned in comparison with its
original. Nothing but the most extraordinary talent can render a tale
of this nature acceptable to the present state of the public appetite.
If not exceedingly good, it is always excessively bad. It must be a
palpable hit or it is nothing. The “Lecture on German Literature” is
in every respect worthy of the talents and learning of its author,
George H. Calvert, Editor of the Baltimore American, and the writer of
several popular works. It is a spirited and accurate sketch of German
Literature from its origin to the present day. The Messenger should
secure Mr. Calvert if possible. “Readings with my pencil, No. IV,” is
a very good paper. “American Social Elevation” is the best
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account