The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 9, August, 1836Various
History
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 9, August, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
It must not be supposed that the absurdities we have here pointed out,
are as obtrusive in the novel of Professor Ingraham as they appear in
our naked digest. Still they are sufficiently so. “_Lafitte_,” like
the “Elkswatawa” of Mr. French, is most successful, we think, in its
historical details. Commodore Patterson and General Andrew Jackson are
among the personages who form a portion of the story. The portrait of
the President seems to us forcibly sketched. But our author is more
happy in any respect than in delineations of character. Some
descriptive pieces are well-drawn, and admirably colored. We may
instance the several haunts of the pirates, the residence of
Velasquez, the house of the council at New Orleans, and the private
cabin allotted by the corsair to Constanza. The whole book possesses
vigor, and a certain species of interest—and there can be little doubt
of its attaining popularity. The chronological mannerism noticed in
“Elkswatawa” is also observable in “Lafitte.” Some other mannerisms
referrible to the same sin of imitation are also to be observed. As a
general rule it may be safely assumed, that the most simple, is the
best, method of narration. Our author cannot be induced to think so,
and is at unnecessary pains to bring about artificialities of
construction—not so much in regard to particular sentences, as to the
introduction of his incidents. To these he always approaches with the
gait of a crab. We have, for example, been keeping company with the
buccaneers for a few pages—but now they are to make an attack upon
some old family mansion. In an instant the buccaneers are dropped for
the mansion, and the definite for the indefinite article. In place of
_the_ robbers proceeding in the course wherein we have been bearing
them company, and advancing in proper order to the dwelling, they are
suddenly abandoned for _a_ house. _A_ family mansion is depicted. _A_
man is sitting within it. _A_ maiden is sitting by his side, and _a_
quantity of ingots are reposing in the cellar. We are then, and not
till then, informed, that the family mansion, the man, the maiden and
the ingots, are the identical mansion, man, maiden and ingots, of
which we have already heard the buccaneers planning the attack.—Thus,
at the conclusion of book the 4th, Count D'Oyley has rescued his
mistress from the cavern, and arrived with her, in safety, upon the
deck of his frigate. He has, moreover, decided upon returning with the
frigate to the cavern for the laudable purpose, as aforesaid, of
hanging his deliverer. We naturally expect still to keep company with
_the_ ship in this adventure; and turn over the page with a certainty
of finding ourselves upon her decks. But not so. She is now merely _a_
frigate which we behold at a distance—_a_ stately ship arrayed in the
apparel of war, and which “sails with majestic motion into the bay of
Gonzales.” Of course we are strongly tempted to throw the book, ship
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account