Later in the day Bilkins was sent for, and arrived at the vicarage much wondering what was in the wind. He wondered still more when he was ushered into the vicar's library, and found himself face to face with Budda, Mr. Tregonning, and Jim Brewer, in addition to the vicar. For several moments he looked from one to another with an expression of utter astonishment on his face. "I have sent for you, Bilkins," said the vicar mildly, "in order to ask you one or two questions that seem of some importance at the present moment." "Yes, sir," said Bilkins, looking, if possible, more puzzled than before. "Can you recall the afternoon on which Sir John Hamblyn was shot?" "Why, yes, sir. Very well, sir." "Did you cross Polskiddy Downs that afternoon?" "I did, sir." "Did you see anybody on the downs?" "Well, only Jim Brewer. We met accidental like." "What was he doing?" "Well, he wasn't doing nothing. He was just standing still with his 'ands in his pockets lookin' round him and whistlin'." "Was he carrying a gun?" "Oh no, sir. He had nothin' in his 'ands." "Did you see a gun?" Bilkins glanced apprehensively at Jim Brewer, and then at the policeman. "Well, no," he said, with considerable hesitation. "I didn't see no gun--that is----" "Did you see any part of a gun?" Mr. Tregonning interjected. "Well, sir, I don't wish to do no 'arm to nobody," Bilkins stammered, growing very red, "but I did see somethin' stickin' out of a furze bush as might have been a gun." "The stock of a gun, perhaps?" "Well, no; but it might 'ave been the barrel." "You did not say anything to Brewer?" "Well, I might, as a kind of joke, 'ave axed him if he 'ad any sport, but it weren't my place to be inquisitive." "And was this far from the plantation?" "Oh no; it were almost close." "Then why, may I ask," interjected the vicar sternly, "did you not volunteer this information when the question was raised as to who shot your master?" "Never thought on it, sir. Jim Brewer is a chap as couldn't hurt nobody." "And yet the fact remains that you saw him close to the plantation on the afternoon on which Sir John was shot, and that no one saw Ralph Penlogan near the place." "Yes, sir," Bilkins said vacantly. "But what explanation or excuse have you to offer for such dereliction of duty?" "For what, sir?" "You must know, surely, that information was sought in all directions that would throw any light on the question." "No one axed me anything, sir." "But you might have told what you knew without being asked." Bilkins looked perplexed, and remained silent. "Why did you not inform someone of what you had seen?" Mr. Tregonning interposed. "Well, you see, sir, Sir John had made up his mind as 'twas young Penlogan as shot him. He see'd his face as he was a-climbing over the hedge, an' he ought to know; and besides, sir, it ain't my place to contradict my betters." "Oh, indeed!" And Mr. Tregonning, as one of his "betters," looked almost as puzzled as Bilkins.