The Standard Cantatas: Their Stories, Their Music, and Their Composers: A HandbookUpton, George P. (George Putnam)
History
The Standard Cantatas: Their Stories, Their Music, and Their Composers: A Handbook
Upton, George P. (George Putnam)
Cantatas -- History and criticism
"It was a pity that those who had commissioned such a composer to write
such a work had so entirely miscalculated their means of presenting it
even respectably. The picturesque old Church of St. Martin is one of
those buildings which swallow up all sound, owing to the curve of the
vaults and the bulk of the piers; the orchestra was little more
powerful, when heard from below, than the distant scraping of a
Christmas serenade far down the street; the chorus was toneless, and
out of tune; and only one solo singer, the soprano, was even tolerable.
On arriving at Liège with the purpose of conducting his work,
Mendelssohn gave up the matter in despair. 'No! it is not good, it
cannot go well, it will make a bad noise,' was his greeting to us....
"We drove with him that afternoon up to St. Martin's Church, to hear,
as he merrily styled it, 'the execution of his music.' The sight of the
steep, narrow, winding street, decked out with fir-trees and banners
and the escutcheons of the different towns of Belgium, pleased him, for
he was as keen a lover of a show as a child, and had a true artist's
quick sense of the picturesque....
"Not envy's self could have helped being in pain for its composer, so
slack and tuneless and ineffective was the execution of this clear and
beautiful work, by a scrannel orchestra, and singers who could hardly
be heard, and who evidenced their nationality by resolutely holding
back every movement. But in the last verse, _alla breve_--
'Ecce panis angelorum'--
there came a surprise of a different quality. It was scenically
accompanied by an unforeseen exposition of the Host, in a gorgeous gilt
tabernacle, that slowly turned above the altar, so as to reveal the
consecrated elements to the congregation. Incense was swung from
censers, and the evening sun, breaking in with a sudden brightness,
gave a fairy-like effect to the curling fumes as they rose; while a
very musical bell, that timed the movement twice in a bar, added its
charm to the rite. I felt a quick grasp on my wrist, as Mendelssohn
whispered to me, eagerly, 'Listen! how pretty that is! it makes amends
for all their bad playing and singing,--and I shall hear the rest
better some other time.' That other time I believe never came for the
composer of the 'Lauda Sion,'--since this was only the year before his
death."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account