This boiler has some obvious defects. It is evident that thin flat plates are the form which, mechanically considered, is least favourable to strength; nor does it appear that any material advantage is gained to compensate for this by the magnitude of the surface exposed to the action of the fire. It is a great defect that a part of the surface of each of the plates is exposed to the action of the fire while it is out of contact with the water; in fact, in the upper part of the spaces marked E, fig. 66., steam only is contained. It has been observed by engineers, and usually shown by experiment, that if steam be heated on the surface of water it will be decomposed, and its elasticity destroyed; this is not the only evil connected with the arrangement, for on this part of the metal, nevertheless, the fire acts,--with less intensity, it is true, than on that part which contains the water,--but still with sufficient intensity to destroy the metal. Mr. _Hancock_ appears to have attempted to remedy this defect by occasionally inverting the position of the flat chambers, placing that which at one time was at the bottom at the top, and _vice versâ_. This may equalise the wear produced by the action of the fire upon the metal out of contact with water, but still the wear on the whole will not be less rapid. There appears to be no provision or space for separating the steam from the water with which it is charged; in fact, there are no means in this engine of discharging the function of Mr. _Gurney's_ separator. This will be found to produce considerable waste and loss of power in practice. The bars upon which the fire rests are of solid metal; and such is the intense heat to which they are subject, that, in an engine constantly at work, it is unlikely that they will last, without being renewed, more than about a week, if so much. The draft is maintained in this engine by means of a revolving fan worked by the engine. This, perhaps, is one of the greatest defects as compared with other locomotives. The quantity of power requisite to work this bellows, and of which the engine is robbed, is very great. This defect is so fatal, that I consider it is quite impossible that the ingenious inventor can persevere in the use of it. Mr. _Hancock_ has abandoned the use of the cranks upon his working axle, and has substituted an endless chain and rag-wheels. This also appears to me defective, and a source by which considerable power is lost. On the other hand, however, the weakness of the axle which is always produced by cranks is avoided. (111.) Mr. _Nathaniel Ogle_ of Southampton obtained a patent for a locomotive carriage, and worked it for some time experimentally; but as his operations do not appear to have been continued, I suppose he was unsuccessful in fulfilling those conditions, without which the machine could not be worked with economy and profit. In his evidence before a committee of the House of Commons, he has thus described his contrivance:--