In relation to our fellow-men, two fundamental points are insisted on
by the Stoics—the duty of justice and the duty of mercy. Cicero,
without doubt following Panætius, [800] describes these two virtues as
the bonds which keep human society together, [801] and, consequently,
gives to each an elaborate treatment. [802] In expanding these duties,
the Stoics were led by the fundamental principles of their system to
most distracting consequences. On the one hand, they required from
their wise men that strict justice which knows no pity and can make no
allowances; [803] hence their ethical system had about it an air of
austerity, and an appearance of severity and cruelty. On the other
hand, their principle of the natural connection of all mankind imposed
on them the practice of the most extended and unreserved charity, of
beneficence, gentleness, meekness, of an unlimited benevolence, and a
readiness to forgive in all cases in which forgiveness is possible.
This last aspect of the Stoic teaching appears principally in the later
Stoics—in Seneca, Epictetus, Marcus Aurelius, and Musonius; [804] and
it is quite possible that they may have given more prominence to it
than their predecessors. But the fact is there, that this aspect is
due, not only to the peculiar character of these individuals, but is
based on the spirit and tone of the whole system. [805]
The question then naturally arises, how these two opposites may be
reconciled—how stern justice may be harmonised with forgiveness and
mercy. Seneca, who investigated the question fully, replies: Not
severity, but only cruelty, is opposed to mercy; for no one virtue is
opposed to another: a wise man will always help another in distress,
but without sharing his emotion, without feeling misery or compassion;
he will not indulge, but he will spare, advise, and improve; he will
not remit punishments in cases in which he knows them to be deserved,
but, from a sense of justice, he will take human weakness into
consideration in allotting punishments, and make every possible
allowance for circumstances. [806] Every difficulty is not, indeed,
removed by these statements; still, those which remain apply more to
the Stoic demand for apathy than to the reconciliation of the two
virtues which regulate our relations to our fellow-men. [807]
[(3) Friendship.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account