Upon closer examination, even the difference between the materialistic
and idealistic description of God vanishes. God, according to Stoic
principles, can only be invested with reality when He has a material
form. Hence, when He is called the Soul, the Mind, or the Reason of the
world, this language does not exclude, but rather presupposes, that
these conceptions have bodies; and such bodies the Stoics thought to
discern in that heated fluid which they at one time call the
all-penetrating Breath, at another Ether, or primary Fire. [317] Each
of these two determinations appeared to them indispensable, [318] and
both became identical by assuming, as the Stoics did, that the infinite
character of the divine Reason depends on the purity and lightness of
the fiery material which composes it. [319] Seneca is therefore only
following out the principles of his School when he pronounces it
indifferent whether God is regarded as Destiny or as an all-pervading
Breath. [320] Those who charge the Stoics with inconsistency for
calling God at one time Reason, at another Soul of the universe, at
another Destiny, at another Fire, Ether, or even the Universe, [321]
forget that they are attaching to these terms a meaning entirely
different from that in which they were used by them. [322]
[(b) God original matter.]
The more the two sides of the conception of God—the material and the
ideal—are compared, the clearer it becomes that there is no difference
between God and primary Matter. Both are one and the same substance,
which, when regarded as the universal substratum, is known as
undetermined matter; but when conceived of as acting force, is called
all-pervading Ether, all-warming Fire, all-penetrating Air, Nature,
Soul of the world, Reason of the world, Providence, Destiny, God.
Matter and power, material and form, are not, as with Aristotle, things
radically different, though united from all eternity. Far from it, the
forming force resides in matter as such; it is in itself something
material; it is identical with Ether, or Fire-element, or Breath. Hence
the difference between efficient and material cause, between God and
matter, resolves itself into the difference between Breath and other
elements. This difference, too, is no original or ultimate difference.
According to the Stoic teaching, every particular element has in
process of time developed out of primary fire or God, and to God it
will return at the end of every period of the world. [323] It is
therefore only a derivative and passing difference with which we are
here concerned. But taking the conception of Deity in its full meaning,
it may be described as primary matter, as well as primary power. The
sum total of all that is real is the divine Breath, moving forth from
itself and returning to itself again. [324] Deity itself is primary
fire, containing in itself in germ both God and matter; [325] the world
in its original gaseous condition; [326] the Universal Substance
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account