The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
What a gift from Heaven was this extraordinary vegetable--a ready
made loaf; reserved, too, till the hour when population, in these
realms at least, began first to increase; and then coming we
scarcely know how. Away with Malthus and his dreary speculations!
The skies are filled with benevolence, and let population
increase how it may, let us not distrust and suppose that men
will ever pick the bones of each other.[84]
Nor was the change in the people’s diet limited to the introduction
of the potato; with it came tea. Of course we know that tea was
drank in England long ere George III. was King, but it was in his
days that tea came into popular use. Here again we may refer to
Buchan, who was strongly opposed to the innovation. He wrote--
It is said the inhabitants of Great Britain consume more tea
than all the other nations of Europe together. The higher ranks
use tea as a luxury, while the lower orders make a diet of it.
The lowest woman in England must have her tea, and the children
generally share it with her. The mischiefs occasioned by tea
arise chiefly from its being substituted for solid food, and had
I time to spare, I think it could not be better employed than
in writing against the destructive drug. Its use will induce a
total change in the constitutions of the people of this country.
Indeed, it has gone a great way towards effecting that evil
already.
What Buchan had not time to do, Cobbett subsequently did, and
some of his most racy patches of vituperation were applied to tea
and tea-drinkers. In Bacon, Bread and Beer, according to Cobbett,
consisted the strength of the English working-man, whilst tea and
potatoes he held in abomination.
To this partial substitution of potatoes and tea for salted animal
food and malt liquor, we may justly attribute the reduction of
the scorbutic habit of the people, and that improvement of health
which were coincident with the close of last century and were
continued into the present. What every student of vital statistics
has to remember is, that conditions have to be identical to yield
identical results. The lives of the majority of the English people
last century, and notably so in London, were hard and sordid to
a degree which in these times is difficult to realise. Their
sanitary conditions have been indicated, and I would now enforce
the observation, that they were ill fed and insufficiently fed;
consequently their diseases were malignant, and smallpox not
unfrequently scarred deeply its scorbutic victims. Wherefore to
run a parallel between the Londoners of the 18th century and the
English of the 19th in the matter of smallpox, and to ascribe
any difference between them to Jenner’s specific, is to display
ignorance that is inexcusable, or craft unscrupulous.
FOOTNOTES:
[76] “On the Uses and Defects of Parish Registers.” By G.M.
Burrows, M.D. In _London Medical Repository_, No. 58, October 1818.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account