The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
In the course of my inquiry, not a single instance occurred of
any one having the disease, either casually or from inoculation,
who on subsequent exposure to variolous contagion received
the infection of smallpox.... Should it appear in the present
instance that I have been led into error, fond as I may appear
of the offspring of my labours, I had rather strangle it at once
than suffer it to exist, and do a public injury. At present, I
have not the most distant doubt that any person, who has once
felt the influence of perfect cowpox matter, would ever be
susceptible of that of the smallpox.
Could universal conclusion be deduced from more questionable
premisses? and this, too, by one who had just exclaimed, “How
very few are capable of conducting physiological experiments!”
Always, as we shall see; ungenerous toward those who questioned his
assertions, Jenner wrote to his friend, Gardner--
This man, Ingenhousz, knows no more of the real nature of
the cowpox than Master Selwyn does of Greek: yet he is among
philosophers what Johnson was among the literati, and, by the
way, not unlike him in figure--
When, in fact, what provoked him was that Ingenhousz knew too
much about cowpox, and had laid his finger on the point of error
at the outset. Inquiry on the part of Ingenhousz brought to light
several other instances of smallpox after cowpox; and Dr. Pulteney
of Blandford reported that Dorsetshire inoculators were familiar
with the one sort of pox after the other sort. Jenner’s constant
answer to such objections was, “Yes; but it could not have been
true cowpox to start with”--a style of argument maintained with
parrot-like persistency when smallpox followed vaccination.
“Ah!” it was said, “there must have been some mistake about the
vaccination; for no one can be thoroughly vaccinated and have
smallpox.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account