The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
This pamphlet appears to have been produced with many pains and
extraordinary apprehensions. Jenner wrote to Gardner, 7th March,
1799--
Every sentence must be again revised and weighed in the nicest
balance that human intellect can invent. The eyes of the
philosophic and medical critic, prejudiced most bitterly against
the hypothesis, will penetrate its inmost recesses, and discover
the minutest flaw were it suffered to be present. Language I put
out of the question: it is the matter I refer to.[112]
These words betray excitement for which there was no warrant; and
when we turn to the treatise that was to be weighed sentence by
sentence in the nicest of balances, it is clearly seen that its
author was a weak-minded creature. It is little more than a gossip
about Cowpox without advance upon the statements of the _Inquiry_.
Indeed, he sets out with the admission--
Although it has not been in my power to extend the Inquiry into
the causes and effects of the Variolæ Vaccinæ much beyond its
original limits, yet, perceiving that it is beginning to excite
a general spirit of investigation, I think it is of importance,
without delay, to communicate such facts as have since occurred,
and to point out the fallacious sources from whence a disease
resembling the true Variolæ Vaccinæ might arise, with the view
of preventing those who may inoculate from producing a spurious
disease; and further, to enforce the precaution suggested in
the former Treatise on the subject, of subduing the inoculated
pustule as soon as it has sufficiently produced its influence on
the constitution. (P. 69.)
Sometimes when it is objected that the evidence adduced in the
_Inquiry_ was hastily collected, meagre and inconclusive, it is
replied, “Yes, but recollect, it was merely a selection, if a poor
one, from the author’s stores”--a reply which Jenner thus renders
nugatory in recording--
My late publication contains a relation of _most of the facts
which had come under my own inspection at the time it was
written_, interspersed with some conjectural observations--(P.
70)--
Which is exactly what any perspicacious reader would infer from
the cases adduced in the _Inquiry_. They were Jenner’s best and
his all. Meanwhile, as observed, he had been able to do little in
extension of the Inquiry; but if idle and helpless, Dr. Pearson had
been active--
Since then Dr. George Pearson has established an inquiry into the
validity of my principal assertion, the result of which cannot
but be highly flattering to my feelings. It contains [Pearson’s
_Inquiry_] not a single case which I think can be called an
exception to the fact I was so firmly impressed with--that the
Cowpox protects the human body from the Smallpox. (P. 70.)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account