The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
To return to the ROYAL JENNERIAN SOCIETY. Its halcyon-days were
of brief duration. Enthusiasm abated, subscriptions fell off,
cases of smallpox after vaccination came to be heard of, and
serious illness and death consequent upon “the benign and harmless
operation.” Opponents waxed bold and could not be silenced. Then
jealousies and dissensions began to operate within the Society.
The financial secretary strove with the medical secretary. Dr.
Walker’s habits and eccentricities, viewed at first with amusement,
excited irritation and disgust, whilst Jenner’s easy-going mode of
life and impecuniosity were a source of scandal and distrust. The
climax was reached in 1806 when Jenner and Walker were set openly
at loggerheads, and a fight to the death ensued.
Walker, it is to be said, never treated Jenner with respect. Like
Pearson he took stock of his merits, and did not rate them highly,
and would not listen to his dictation. “Vaccination,” he used to
observe, “is extremely simple as to facts, while, as to causes,
it is entirely out of the reach of medical men with all their
theories.” Jenner, as president of the Medical Council, thought he
had a right to be obeyed, but Walker was the last man in the world
to yield obedience when he had formed an opposite conviction--
Jenner [writes Baron] considered it his duty to admonish him,
and repeatedly represented to him, in the most friendly manner,
the mischievous tendency of his innovations. These remonstrances
were unavailing, and he ceased to have any communication with Dr.
Walker after the summer of 1805; submitting rather to lament in
silence the fate of the Society than come before it as a public
accuser.
Of course such forbearance could not last long, and instructions
issued by Walker to the Nottingham Vaccine Institution in March,
1806, were made the occasion of an open rupture. Jenner brought
Walker’s conduct under the consideration of the Medical Council,
and secured his condemnation. The question was then referred
to the General Court of the Society on the 25th of July, when a
motion that Walker he dismissed from his office was negatived by a
majority of three, Walker being supported by Sir Joseph Banks and
Jenner by Dr. Sims. But the victory was not satisfactory to Walker,
and on the 8th of August he put an end to the strife by sending in
his resignation.
Baron’s solemn account of the contest must appal every ingenuous
reader. Jenner, it is written, regarded Walker’s proceedings as of
“the most dangerous character,” as “placing in peril the safety of
the practice,” and “as likely to wreck the Society”; so that had
he not retired Jenner would have been compelled to withdraw his
countenance from Salisbury Square. As we read we exclaim, Whatever
did the dreadful Doctor do? Here is Baron’s answer--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account