The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
Should this report from the Physicians corroborate the favourable
opinion of Vaccination entertained by foreign nations, it must
greatly tend to subdue those prejudices against the practice which
have been fomented here. And in that case, the House may consider
whether the ingenious Discoverer has been remunerated conformably
to the liberal spirit and character of this country.
Dr. MATHEWS seconded the motion, and contrasted the safety of the
vaccine with the dangers of variolous inoculation. He had no doubt
the country would hasten to testify still further its gratitude to
the learned physician to whom they owed this inestimable benefit.
Mr. WILBERFORCE did not approve of the reference to the College of
Physicians. He would have preferred an investigation by a committee
of the House, and another committee of the House of Lords. The
opinions of such unbiased persons would be more congenial to
the feelings of the people, and far more satisfactory than any
medical report from the College of Physicians. The latter might be
suspected of being influenced by professional motives, whereas a
report from the Lords and Commons would be universally received as
proceeding from a pure desire to promote the general good. It did
not surprise him that Vaccination had made less progress at home
than abroad. The resistance was due to that curious principle in
the human mind which accepts what comes from afar with admiration
whilst what is familiar is neglected and despised. The remedy would
be found in diffusing information as to the complete success of
Vaccination in foreign countries. They would thus disperse those
absurd prejudices which are engendered and fostered by certain
selfish and interested individuals.
Mr. WINDHAM did not concur in the advice of Mr. Wilberforce to
refer the matter to a parliamentary committee. It was a question
for medical men. To a committee of the House the adage might be
applied, _Ne sutor ultra crepidam_. Let them enforce with their
approval the report of the physicians, and then let them proceed
to remunerate that meritorious individual to whom society owed
the utmost gratitude. He could not help thinking he had not yet
received what was due for the expense and trouble the discovery had
cost him.
Mr. BANKS was of a sceptical turn. He wished the motion had been
made earlier in the session, for then he should have supported
the suggestion of Mr. Wilberforce. They wished to know whether
Vaccination really did afford reasonable security from smallpox.
It was not a question for medical men for which the House was
incompetent. They were as capable of determining the point, and
setting it clearly before the public, as the most learned body that
ever existed. He wished too, since the motion would be carried,
that the Royal College of Surgeons might be united with the
Physicians in the production of the report. As for Dr. Jenner, if
Vaccination were as efficacious as asserted, he might be left to
find his reward in its practice.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account