The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
In _almost_ every case where Smallpox has succeeded Vaccination,
the disease has varied much from its ordinary course; it has
neither been the same in violence, nor in the duration of its
symptoms, but has, _with very few exceptions_, been remarkably
mild, as if the Smallpox had been deprived, by the previous
vaccine disease, of all its usual malignity.
It goes without saying, that such a statement was quackish romance.
How could a physician know that any case of Smallpox had been made
milder by Vaccination? for how could he know how severe the disease
would have been without Vaccination? Any ground of comparison
was wanting. Smallpox is an eruptive fever of wide degrees of
intensity--slight as to be a trivial ailment, severe as to be
inevitably fatal. “So true,” wrote Dr. Wagstaffe in 1722, “is that
common observation, that there is one sort in which a nurse cannot
kill, and another which even a physician cannot cure.” Yet every
case of mild Smallpox after Cowpox came into fashion was placed to
the credit of Vaccination!
Some writers [the Report continues] have greatly undervalued
the security Vaccination affords, while others have considered
it to be of a temporary nature only; but if any reliance is to
be placed on the statements laid before the College, its power
of protecting the human body from Smallpox, _though not perfect
indeed_, is abundantly sufficient to recommend it to the prudent
and dispassionate. The opinion that Vaccination affords but a
temporary security is supported by no analogy in Nature, nor by
the facts which have hitherto occurred.
The analogy of Nature was a treacherous support, whilst the
Physicians did not foresee the time when their successors would
plead the fact of the temporary security of Vaccination as a reason
for systematic Re-Vaccination.
It is not difficult to discern between the lines of the Report a
spirit of doubt and hesitation. Those who framed it had gone too
far to turn back; there was Jenner on their hands; and a public
ready to hoot if there was any open apostasy. The outlook at home
was not encouraging, but there was the Continent, yea more, the
wide world itself wherein to cover the reproach of failure--
They could not be insensible [said the Physicians] to the
confirmation they receive not only from the introduction of
Vaccination into every part of Europe, _but throughout the vast
Continents of Asia and America_.
The vast Continents of Asia and America! A fine phrase--a very fine
phrase, with more comfort in it than scoffers might imagine.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account