The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
He preferred to be adjudged mistaken rather than risk
the forfeit of public favour and pay. Nor might I blame him, had he
frankly reasserted the integrity of the Gloucestershire faith, and
allowed that since the public were ready to accept Cowpox without
Horsegrease, it was not for him to stand in the way of their
preference by an obstinate defence of what was non-essential in
practice.
But the case for Horsegrease was yet stronger than I have stated.
Dr. Sacco of Milan was sometimes described as “the prince of
vaccinators” by reason of his enthusiasm, his professional
attainments, and the facilities that were accorded to him in
the Cisalpine Republic of those days for universal vaccination.
He tried to generate pox on the cow with grease from the horse,
but failed, and in 1801 reported to Jenner his failure. In 1803,
however, he cried, Eureka! A coachman presented himself at the
Milan Hospital suffering from an eruption contracted in grooming
a horse with greasy heels. He was at once led off by Sacco to the
Foundling Asylum, where nine children were inoculated from the
vesicles on his hands. On three of the children the inoculation
took, producing vesicles which were pronounced to be the same as
those resulting from Cowpox. The virus was propagated from arm to
arm, and distributed in all directions. Dr. Sacco from thenceforth
avowed himself a Horsegreaser. “It is now admitted and settled,” he
wrote to Jenner from Milan, 25th March, 1803, “that grease is the
cause of vaccine, and we cannot too soon alter the designation to
equine.”
Was the designation changed to equine? It was not, nor was the
attempt made. Those chiefly concerned in promoting vaccination in
England would not hear of Horsegrease, and many were ready to swear
that in the matter of pox, the horse and the cow had no connection
whatever, and that Jenner had too hastily assumed the truth of a
vulgar west country opinion.
Dr. De Carro of Vienna, who described himself as Jenner’s friend
and first apostle, having effected the first vaccination on the
Continent and transmitted the first charge of vaccine to India,
was also a Horsegreaser. Whilst Jenner was judiciously holding
his tongue about Horsegrease in England, he wrote to De Carro
congratulating him on his success in conveying Cowpox to the
East, and ascribing the failure of the English attempts to the
absurd prejudice against Horsegrease, which Dr. Loy had, however,
completely annihilated. Here are his words under date, 28th March,
1803--
I am confident that had not the opponents of my ideas of the
origin of the disease been so absurdly clamorous, particularly
the _par nobile fratrum_ [Pearson and Woodville], the Asiatics
would long since have enjoyed the blessings of Vaccination, and
many a victim been rescued from an untimely grave. The decisive
experiments of Dr. Loy have silenced the tongues of these
gentlemen for ever.[146]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account