The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
In order to discredit Rowley, it is thought fair policy to connect
him with such nonsense, and to have it supposed that he rested
his case upon “the cowpoxed ox-faced boy:” it was far otherwise.
He diligently tracked the vaccinators, and accumulated 504
cases of smallpox and injury after vaccination with 75 deaths,
particulars being accurately specified. Nor was he content merely
to report what he had ascertained. “Come and see,” was his forcible
argument. “I have lately had under my care,” he wrote, “some
of the worst species of malignant smallpox in the Marylebone
Infirmary, which many of the faculty have examined and know to
have been vaccinated.” His trust in “Come and see,” he still more
powerfully exemplified in an exhibition of the injuries inflicted
by vaccination in his Lecture Room in Savile Row in October, 1805.
“Knowing,” he said, “the caviling character of the Cowpoxers,
I determined to leave them no hole for retreat”; and therefore
he brought together Joules, “the ox-faced boy, who also had a
terribly diseased elbow-joint”; Marianne Lewis, the mangey girl,
“who was covered with blotches like a leopard”; “a load of children
in a cart from the south of London,” and others accompanied by
their parents, and displaying their various maladies, said, “Behold
the effects of the new disease that has been taken from the cow and
implanted in humanity!” This painful exposition was continued over
two days, and as he records, “the scene was truly affecting and
distressing to all who witnessed it.” An antagonist like Rowley is
a serious factor in any controversy, and we may estimate the havoc
he wrought by the extreme anxiety of the Jennerites to have him
estimated by the supposed absurdity of the ox-faced boy.
To a man of practical temper like Rowley, the enthusiasm with which
vaccination was at first advocated appeared akin to delirium--
I have been in some vaccination storms, and have had the buttons
torn off my coat, cloth and all, to convince me of the great and
infallible excellence of Cowpox. I have seen some of the vehement
vaccinators redden like a flame with fury, their lips quivering,
their eyes starting out of their heads, their mouths foaming,
their tongues dropping hard words, and their fists clenched like
pugilists, ready to accompany their violent wrath with other
knock-down arguments. In such circumstances, mild, investigating
Philosophy quits the scene and leaves the field of battle to the
Bedlamites.
The fury had subsided in 1805, and Rowley held that many medical
men were deeply ashamed of the extravagance into which they had
been committed, but lacked courage to make frank confession.
Rowley died in 1806, and the regard in which he was held was
manifest in the crowds who flocked to his funeral. In the _Roll of
Physicians_, Dr. Munk observes--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account