The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
Nor was vaccination merely forced on Cobbett’s attention as a
popular craze. He had to deal with it as a possible compulsory
infliction. At a public meeting in 1803, Wilberforce and Dr.
Clarke advocated the prohibition of smallpox inoculation and the
enforcement of vaccination; and Cobbett, in a letter addressed to
Wilberforce, rebuked the arbitrary project in a strain impressive
and dignified as that of Burke himself. He wrote--
It seems there are prejudices against cowpox which it is
necessary to destroy by force. That there are prejudices, and
very strong ones too, I am ready to allow, but I cannot agree
that these prejudices should be eradicated by force; nor is it
perhaps fair to use the degrading term as expressive of the
dislike which so large a portion of the community entertain to
the practice you are so anxious to compel them to adopt. The
charge of prejudice has been preferred but too often, and with
but too fatal success against every one opposed to change. The
truth is that whoever has been found to object to innovation,
however wild in itself, however destructive in its consequences,
has constantly been accused of prejudice; and as prejudice thus
used implies a mixture of _ignorance_ and _perverseness_, and as
few persons are willing to be thought ignorant and perverse, the
imputation is employed to coerce assent where reason hesitates.
He then aptly applied the repudiated recommendation of inoculation
with smallpox as cause for hesitation in assenting to inoculation
with cowpox--
There was, you must well remember, a strong and general
objection, which for a long time prevailed, against Inoculation
with Smallpox; and you cannot have forgotten that this objection
was termed _prejudice_, and the persons entertaining it were
regarded as _illiterate_, _ignorant_, or _perverse_; yet it now
appears from the Address of your Royal Jennerian Society that
it would have been well for the human race if the prejudices of
those illiterate, ignorant, or perverse persons had universally
obtained; for you now tell us that “Inoculation by spreading the
contagion has considerably increased the mortality of Smallpox.”
With an example like this before our eyes, Ought we not to be
very cautious how we adopt your new system of Inoculation with
Cowpox?
Then turning upon Wilberforce in his favourite character of
constitutional Englishman, he proceeded--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account