The Struggle for Imperial Unity: Recollections & ExperiencesDenison, George T. (George Taylor)
History
The Struggle for Imperial Unity: Recollections & Experiences
Denison, George T. (George Taylor)
Canada -- History -- 1867-1914
I ask the Press Association if it is fair to their fellow-Canadians to
allow our bitterest and most dangerous enemy to speak on behalf of our
country? Is it fair to ask a loyal man like the Hon. G. W. Ross, who
believes in Canada, to be coupled with a traitor?
Among the other methods of arousing the patriotic feeling of our people
was the erection of monuments on our great battlefields in memory of
the victories gained in the struggle to preserve the freedom of our
country in 1812-'14.
The Lundy's Lane Historical Society, one of the patriotic organisations
which sprang up over the Province, had started a movement for erecting
a monument on the field of Lundy's Lane where the last important and
the most hotly contested battle of the war took place in July, 1814.
They had collected a number of subscriptions but not sufficient for
the purpose, when Goldwin Smith offered through the late Oliver A.
Howland to supply the balance required, provided that he might write
the inscription so as to include both armies in the commemoration on
equal terms. This offer was promptly declined by the Society, which had
no desire to honour invaders who had made a most unprovoked attack upon
a sparse people, who had nothing whatever to do with the assumed cause
of the quarrel.
Shortly after, the Canadian Government took the matter in hand, and
provided the balance required for the Lundy's Lane Monument, and the
full amounts required for monuments on the fields of Chateauguay and
Chrysler's Farm.
The Lundy's Lane Monument was finished and ready to be unveiled on
the anniversary of the battle, the 25th July, 1895, and the Secretary
of State, the Hon. W. H. Montague, had promised to unveil it and
deliver an address. The day before Dr. Montague telegraphed to me that
he could not go, and asked me to go on behalf of the Government and
unveil the monument. I agreed, and he telegraphed to the President
of the Society that I was coming. About two thousand people were
assembled. It will be remembered that Mr. Goldwin Smith had commented
severely upon the proposal to put up a monument at Lundy's Lane, in
his lecture on "Jingoism" delivered in 1891. He said, "Only let it
be like that monument at Quebec, a sign at once of gratitude and of
reconciliation, not of the meanness of unslaked hatred." I replied to
this in my lecture on "National Spirit" shortly after, and said that
the Professor, "considering how he is always treating a country that
has used him far better than he ever deserved, should be a first-class
authority on the meanness of unslaked and unfounded hatred."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account