The Surgery of the Skull and BrainRawling, Louis Bathe
Science
The Surgery of the Skull and Brain
Rawling, Louis Bathe
Brain -- Surgery; Skull -- Surgery
The general details of the operation as enumerated above may require
amendment as our knowledge increases. Sufficient has been said,
however, to point out the various methods of approach and the advantages
claimed for the nasal route.
=Results of operation on brain tumours.= Statistics are always
fallacious, and this is especially the case with regard to operations on
tumours of the brain. Few surgeons have operated on a sufficient number
of cases to compile satisfactory statistical tables. These tables are
generally made up from the combined experience of many operators, all
using their own methods. The following, however, will serve to give an
approximate idea as to mortality, &c.
_Mortality._ From earlier records the immediate mortality was estimated
at 30-40 per cent. Duret, however, records 400 cases with a mortality of
19·5 per cent., 58 cases dying from shock, 10 from hyperpyrexia, and 10
from hæmorrhage. In my own practice, the mortality may be estimated at a
much lower figure. Perhaps I may be too conservative, but I hold the
view that, unless the tumour is readily exposed and equally readily
removable, it is inadvisable to carry out further measures for its
eradication. Moreover, the general technique of brain surgery has
advanced with rapid strides, and the question of early and accurate
localization has received equal attention. The mortality has diminished
proportionately, and may be estimated at less than 20 per cent. So much
depends on the surgeon and on the nature of the tumour, its position and
localization, that it is impossible to make any absolute statement as to
the risk to life attendant on operation. If all tumours were fibromata,
cortically situated, and accurately diagnosed, the operation, in the
hands of a skilled neurological surgeon, should present but a very low
mortality. So long, however, as surgeons will persist in burrowing into
the brain substance for a supposed subcortical tumour, so long will the
mortality remain high. The great secret in operating on a brain tumour
lies in knowing when to terminate the attempt at removal of the tumour
and when to rest content with a pure ‘decompression’.
It is obvious, therefore, that cortical tumours--more especially such as
give rise to early localizing symptoms, e.g. Rolandic tumours--offer a
better prognosis than when the surgeon has to deal with subcortical,
central, and basal tumour formation.
_The mortality according to the region affected._ The following table,
from a series collected by Knapp, supplies valuable information as to
the regional mortality.
Frontal tumours 32 cases Mortality, 25 per cent.
Central „ 231 „ „ 23 „
Parietal „ 29 „ „ 41 „
Temporal „ 17 „ „ 29 „
Occipital „ 10 „ „ 20 „
Cerebellar „ 54 „ „ 45 „
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account