"The System," As Uncovered by the San Francisco Graft ProsecutionHichborn, Franklin
History
"The System," As Uncovered by the San Francisco Graft Prosecution
Hichborn, Franklin
Political corruption -- California -- San Francisco; San Francisco (Calif.) -- Politics and government
[195] The refusal of Calhoun and Mullally to testify created a
sensation, even in those sensational times. The Chronicle in
its issue of May 4, 1907, printed the following account of the
incident:
"For the first time in the history of the examination of
witnesses before this Grand Jury, Heney was careful not to
instruct the prospective witnesses as to their legal rights.
Instead he merely asked them if they were already familiar
with their rights under the law.
"'I am aware,' said Calhoun, who was the first to be called,
'that anything I might tell this body might be used against
me.'
"'With that understanding are you willing to become a witness
before this Grand Jury?' asked Heney.
"'I am not,' was Calhoun's response.
"The Jurymen who had leaned forward as the reply of the
president hung on his lips sank back in their seats.
"'That is all, Mr. Calhoun,' said Heney to the president, and
then going to the door he said to the bailiff, 'Call Mr.
Mullally.'
"Mullally's examination was identical with that of his
superior's and he was permitted to go. Neither President
Calhoun nor Assistant Mullally will be called again to the jury
room."
Calhoun issued the following statement of his refusal to
testify:
"When called before the Grand Jury this afternoon and informed
that it had under investigation the alleged bribery of public
officials by the United Railroads, we declined to be sworn and
in order that our action may not be misconstrued, I call your
attention to these facts:
"For months past the public prints have been full of charges
traceable to certain persons connected with the prosecution
that they had positive evidence that the United Railroads had
spent not less than $450,000 in bribing the officials of this
city. I have repeatedly stated that neither I nor the United
Railroads, nor any official of the United Railroads, had bribed
anyone, authorized any bribery, knew of any bribery or approved
of any bribery. This statement I now fully reaffirm. It is not
for us nor any officer of our company to disprove these grave
charges. It is for those making them to prove them. We do not
now care to discuss their motives. We know that they cannot
produce any truthful evidence connecting us or any officer of
the United Railroads with this alleged crime.
"We relied, in declining to be sworn, upon the broad
Constitutional right of every American citizen that a defendant
cannot be called as a witness, and upon the justice, fairness
and common sense of the Grand Jury, to whom we look for
complete vindication without offering one word in our own
behalf."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account