"The System," As Uncovered by the San Francisco Graft ProsecutionHichborn, Franklin
History
"The System," As Uncovered by the San Francisco Graft Prosecution
Hichborn, Franklin
Political corruption -- California -- San Francisco; San Francisco (Calif.) -- Politics and government
"Some days after he had introduced himself to me he stepped up
to me, just as court had adjourned and after I had been
examining some of the grand jurors as to their qualifications,
and said in substance:
"'Mr. Heney, it seems to me that you discriminate somewhat
against the Jews in examining jurors, and I think that in your
position you ought to be more careful not to exhibit any
prejudice against a man on account of his religion.'
"I asked what in particular I had done to cause him to
criticise my conduct in that way, and he referred to some
question which I had asked a grand juror, but which I cannot
now recollect. I then said to him in substance:
"'Why, Doctor, you are supersensitive. Some of the best friends
I have in the world are Jews, and some of the best clients I
ever had in my life were Jews, and I have no prejudice against
any man merely on account of his religious belief. I am sorry
that you have so misapprehended the purpose and motives of my
questions to jurors.'
"On a subsequent day, during the time the Grand Jury was being
impaneled, Dr. Nieto again approached me after an adjournment
of the court and again reproached me for having again shown
prejudice or discrimination against some grand juror of the
Jewish faith by the questions which I asked him * * * and I
said to him in substance, in a very emphatic tone of voice:
'Dr. Nieto, I have heretofore told you that I have no prejudice
against any man whatever on account of his religion. All I am
trying to do in this matter is to get fair grand jurors, and I
am just as willing to trust honest Jews as honest Christians,
but I want to make sure that a man is honest, whether a Jew or
Christian, and it looks to me as if you are trying to find some
excuse to line up in opposition to this prosecution. I do not
see why you need to seek for excuses if that is what you want
to do. I am conscious of my own singleness of purpose and
purity of purpose in examining grand jurors, and it is wholly
immaterial to me, therefore, what you or anybody else may think
of my method of questioning them.'"
As a matter of fact Jews not only sat on the Oliver Grand Jury,
but were among the most earnest and effective in sifting the
graft scandal to the bottom. But that the false cry that Ruef
was persecuted because he was a Jew influenced many of his
fellow Jews in his favor is unquestionably true.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account