If the postulate is assumed that a straight line is the shortest path
between two points, then the first part of this theorem requires no
further proof, and the second part follows at once from the axiom of
inequalities. This seems the better plan for beginners, and the
proposition may be considered as semiobvious. Euclid proved the first
part, not having assumed the postulate. Proclus tells us that the
Epicureans (the followers of Epicurus, the Greek philosopher, 342-270
B.C.) used to ridicule this theorem, saying that even an ass knew it,
for if he wished to get food, he walked in a straight line and not along
two sides of a triangle. Proclus replied that it was one thing to know
the truth and another thing to prove it, meaning that the value of
geometry lay in the proof rather than in the mere facts, a thing that
all who seek to reform the teaching of geometry would do well to keep in
mind. The theorem might simply appear as a corollary under the postulate
if it were of any importance to reduce the number of propositions one
more.
If the proposition is postponed until after those concerning the
inequalities of angles and sides of a triangle, there are several good
proofs.
[Illustration]
For example, produce _AC_ to _X_,
making
_CX_ = _CB_.
Then [L]_X_ = [L]_XBC_.
[therefore] [L]_XBA_ > [L]_X_.
[therefore] _AX_ > _AB_.
[therefore] _AC_ + _CB_ > _AB_.
The above proof is due to Euclid. Heron of Alexandria (first century
A.D.) is said by Proclus to have given the following:
[Illustration]
Let _CX_ bisect [L]_C_.
Then [L]_BXC_ > [L]_ACX_.
[therefore] [L]_BXC_ > [L]_XCB_.
[therefore] _CB_ > _XB_.
Similarly, _AC_ > _AX_.
Adding, _AC_ + _CB_ > _AB_.
THEOREM. _If two sides of a triangle are unequal, the angles opposite
these sides are unequal, and the angle opposite the greater side is the
greater._
Euclid stated this more briefly by saying, "In any triangle the greater
side subtends the greater angle." This is not so satisfactory, for there
may be no greater side.
THEOREM. _If two angles of a triangle are unequal, the sides opposite
these angles are unequal, and the side opposite the greater angle is the
greater._
Euclid also stated this more briefly, but less satisfactorily, thus, "In
any triangle the greater angle is subtended by the greater side."
Students should have their attention called to the fact that these two
theorems are reciprocal or dual theorems, the words "sides" and
"angles" of the one corresponding to the words "angles" and "sides"
respectively of the other.
It may also be noticed that the proof of this proposition
involves what is known as the Law of Converse; for
(1) if _b_ = _c_, then [L]_B_ = [L]_C_;
(2) if _b_ > _c_, then [L]_B_ > [L]_C_;
(3) if _b_ < _c_, then [L]_B_ < [L]_C_;
therefore the converses must necessarily be true as a matter of
logic; for
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account