In a few minutes they were in the bookroom. Paynton seated himself in such a position as to place his back to the strong light shining through the window, and asked Claude to be seated in a chair which lacked this advantage. In this way Paynton could observe every change in the face of his visitor, while his own, being in the shadow, was more difficult to read. Larcher saw the maneuver, but did not think it necessary to make any objection. In his place Tait would have acted differently. "I am greatly obliged that you have consented to see me," said Claude, breaking the silence, "for I am informed that you live a very secluded life." "That is true. I accord you this interview at the request of my friend, Mr. Hilliston, but at the same time I may tell you that I have my own reasons for granting it." "I think I can guess your reasons, Mr. Paynton." "No doubt," replied Paynton, touching a book on the table; "they are not unconnected with this novel. You know, of course, that my daughter--that Jenny supplied young Linton with the material for his plot." "I do. She found the report of my father's murder in some old newspapers in this house." "Did you not think it strange that I should be in possession of such a report?" "Naturally I did," answered Claude, replying to this direct question with marked embarrassment, "and it is on that account that I ask you to help me." "Do you think I can do so?" "I am sure of it." "Why?" asked Paynton, in an unsteady voice. "Because you know about the matter. You retained the report of the trial. Denis Bantry is in your service under the name of Kerry, and----" "How do you know that?" "Why, in the third volume of that book there is an episode of a scarfpin which is not mentioned in the report of the trial, but which was told to Miss Paynton by the man you call Kerry. Now, only two persons knew that a scarfpin was picked up in the grounds of The Laurels after the murder. One was Hilliston, the other Denis Bantry. You must see, Mr. Paynton, that I can only come to one conclusion." "I presume you got this information from Hilliston," said Paynton, in an altered voice. "Mr. Hilliston spoke of it," replied Claude cautiously. He did not intend to reveal that he had heard it from his mother, or indeed to reveal the existence of Mrs. Larcher until he was sure of his ground, and positive of Paynton's identity. Accepting his diplomatic answer in the affirmative, Paynton nodded, and went on with his questioning. "You spoke to Kerry on the subject?" "I did. But, as you may guess, I failed." "Naturally. Kerry is a faithful servant. I owe more to him than I can ever repay. But here we are talking about the murder," added Paynton irrelevantly, "when you wish to speak about Jenny, at least so Hilliston informed me." "I do wish to speak of your daughter later on," said Claude, with a flushed cheek; "but in the meantime I am anxious to come to an understanding about this crime."