The Thirteenth, Greatest of CenturiesWalsh, James J. (James Joseph)
History
The Thirteenth, Greatest of Centuries
Walsh, James J. (James Joseph)
Civilization, Medieval -- 13th century; Universities and colleges -- History
Those who have any doubts as to the place of Gothic art itself in art
history and who need an authority always to bolster up the opinion
that they may hold, will find ample support in the enthusiastic
opinion of an authority whom we have quoted already. The most
interesting and significant feature of his ardent expression of
enthusiasm is his comparison of Romanesque with Gothic art in this
respect. The amount of ground covered from one artistic mode to the
other is greater than any other advance in art that has ever been
made. After all, the real value of the work of the period must be
judged, rather by the amount of progress that has {106} been made than
by the stage of advance actually reached, since it is development
rather than accomplishment that counts in the evolution of the race.
On the other hand it will be found that Reinach's opinion of the
actual attainments of Gothic art are far beyond anything that used to
be thought on the subject a half century ago, and much higher than any
but a few of the modern art critics hold in the matter. He says:
"In contrast to this Romanesque art, as yet in bondage to
convention, ignorant or disdainful of nature, the mature Gothic art
of the Thirteenth Century appeared as a brilliant revival or
realism. The great sculptors who adorned the Cathedrals of Paris,
Amiens, Rheims, and Chartres with their works, were realists in the
highest sense of the word. They sought in Nature not only their
knowledge of human forms, and of the draperies that cover them, but
also that of the principles of decoration. Save in the gargoyles of
cathedrals and in certain minor sculptures, we no longer find in the
Thirteenth Century those unreal figures of animals, nor those
ornaments, complicated as nightmares, which load the capitals of
Romanesque churches; the flora of the country, studied with loving
attention, is the sole, or almost the sole source from which
decorators take their motives. It is in this charming profusion of
flowers and foliage that the genius of Gothic architecture is most
freely displayed. One of the most admirable of its creations is the
famous Capital of the Vintage in Notre Dame at Rheims, carved about
the year 1250. Since the first century of the Roman Empire art had
never imitated Nature so perfectly, nor has it ever since done so
with a like grace and sentiment."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account