Asia -- Description and travel -- Early works to 1800; Mongols -- History; Polo, Marco, 1254-1323?; Voyages and travels
NOTE 2.—I confess that the indications in this and the beginning
of the following chapter are, to me, full of difficulty. According
to the general style of Polo’s itinerary, the 2½ days should be
reckoned from Yung-ch’ang; the distance therefore to the capital
city of Mien would be 17½ days. The real capital of Mien or Burma
at this time was, however, Pagán, in lat. 21° 13′, and that city
could hardly have been reached by a land traveller in any such
time. We shall see that something may be said in behalf of the
supposition that the point reached was _Tagaung_ or _Old Pagán_,
on the upper Irawadi, in lat. 23° 28′; and there was perhaps some
confusion in the traveller’s mind between this and the great city.
The descent might then be from Yung-ch’ang to the valley of the
Shwéli, and that valley then followed to the Irawadi. Taking as a
scale Polo’s 5 marches from Tali to Yung-ch’ang, I find we should
by this route make just about 17 marches from Yung-ch’ang to
Tagaung. We have no detailed knowledge of the route, but there _is_
a road that way, and by no other does the plain country approach
so near to Yung-ch’ang. (See _Anderson’s Report on Expedition to
Western Yunnan_, p. 160.)
Dr. Anderson’s remarks on the present question do not in my
opinion remove the difficulties. He supposes the long descent to
be the descent into the plains of the Irawadi near Bhamo; and from
that point the land journey to Great Pagán could, he conceives,
“easily be accomplished in 15 days.” I greatly doubt the latter
assumption. By the scale I have just referred to it would take at
least 20 days. And to calculate the 2½ days with which the journey
commences from an indefinite point seems scarcely admissible. Polo
is giving us a continuous _itinerary_; it would be ruptured if he
left an indefinite distance between his last station and his “long
descent.” And if the same principle were applied to the 5 days
between Carajan (or Tali) and Vochan (Yung-ch’ang), the result
would be nonsense.
[Illustration: Temple of Gaudapalén (in the city of Mien), erected
_circa_ A.D. 1160.]
[_Mien-tien_, to which is devoted ch. vii. of the Chinese work
_Sze-i-kwan-k’ao_, appears to have included much more than Burma
proper. (See the passage _supra_, pp. 70–71, quoted by Devéria from
the _Yuen-shi lei pien_ regarding _Kien-tou_ and _Kin-Chi_.)—H. C.]
The hypothesis that I have suggested would suit better with the
traveller’s representation of the country traversed as wild and
uninhabited. In a journey to Great Pagán the most populous and
fertile part of Burma would be passed through.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account