Asia -- Description and travel -- Early works to 1800; Mongols -- History; Polo, Marco, 1254-1323?; Voyages and travels
NOTE 4.—As regards Bayan personally, and the main body under his
command, this seems to be incorrect. His advance took place from
Siang-yang along the lines of the Han River and of the Great Kiang.
Another force indeed marched direct upon Yang-chau, and therefore
probably by Hwai-ngan chau (_infra_, p. 152); and it is noted
that Bayan’s orders to the generals of this force were to spare
bloodshed. (_Gaubil_, 159; _D’Ohsson_, II. 398.)
NOTE 5.—So in our own age ran the Hindu prophecy that Bhartpúr
should never fall till there came a great alligator against it; and
when it fell to the English assault, the Brahmans found that the
name of the leader was COMBERMERE = _Kumhír-Mír_, the Crocodile
Lord!
——“Be those juggling fiends no more believed
That palter with us in a double sense;
That keep the word of promise to our ear
And break it to our hope!”
It would seem from the expression, both in Pauthier’s text and in
the G. T., as if Polo intended to say that _Chincsan_ (Cinqsan)
meant “One Hundred Eyes”; and if so we could have no stronger proof
of his ignorance of Chinese. It is _Pe-yen_, the Chinese form of
_Bayan_, that means, or rather may be punningly rendered, “One
Hundred Eyes.” Chincsan, _i.e._ _Ching-siang_, was the title of the
superior ministers of state at Khanbaligh, as we have already seen.
The title occurs pretty frequently in the Persian histories of the
Mongols, and frequently as a Mongol title in Sanang Setzen. We find
it also disguised as _Chyansam_ in a letter from certain Christian
nobles at Khanbaligh, which Wadding quotes from the Papal archives.
(See _Cathay_, pp. 314–315.)
But it is right to observe that in the Ramusian version the
mistranslation which we have noticed is not so undubitable:
“Volendo sapere come avea nome il Capitano nemico, le fu detto,
_Chinsambaian_, cioè _Cent’occhi_.”
A kind of corroboration of Marco’s story, but giving a different
form to the pun, has been found by Mr. W. F. Mayers, of the
Diplomatic Department in China, in a Chinese compilation dating
from the latter part of the 14th century. Under the heading, “_A
Kiang-nan Prophecy_,” this book states that prior to the fall of
the Sung a prediction ran through Kiang-nan: “If Kiang-nan fall, a
hundred wild geese (_Pê-yen_) will make their appearance.” This,
it is added, was not understood till the generalissimo _Peyen
Chingsiang_ made his appearance on the scene. “Punning prophecies
of this kind are so common in Chinese history, that the above is
only worth noticing in connection with Marco Polo’s story.” (_N.
and Q., China and Japan_, vol. ii. p. 162.)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account