The tribes and castes of the North-Western Provinces and Oudh, Volume 1 (of 4)Crooke, William
History
The tribes and castes of the North-Western Provinces and Oudh, Volume 1 (of 4)
Crooke, William
Caste -- India -- History; Hindus -- India; Tribes -- India -- History
“I have excluded the casteless tribes, but have included the Bâgdi, a
so-called caste, though why so termed, except that it is found in the
plains of India and has been largely Hinduised, is not apparent. This
confusion between the two terms must continue so long as the functional
character of caste is not admitted. The Bâgdis, like the Bauris, are a
tribe as much as the Kol or the Santâl, and being Drâvirs by race,
stand apart in the foregoing statement with a generally well-marked
Dravidian type of face. The other four groups are functional, their
occupations being that of priest, writer, cowherd and leather dresser;
and though there is a greater coarseness of feature in the two latter,
who are out-of-door labourers, than in the former, who are gentle-born,
all four are manifestly of the same race or rather of the same amalgam
of races. The first five Brâhmans and Kâyasths have distinctly
Caucasian features, but the average index of the second five Brâhmans
(86·3) shows a much greater approach to the flatnosedness of the Negro
than the similar average of Goâlas (84·7), or Chamârs (84·9). In fact
the two last Brâhmans have a more aboriginal type of face than any of
the despised leather-dressers. It is probable and natural that there
should be a greater admixture of non-Aryan blood in persons pursuing
the humbler occupations, and this is the gist of Mr. Nesfield’s
argument, which seems triumphantly corroborated by the foregoing
figures. The race theory of castes, on the other hand, is found to have
practically no statistical support. Far from its being a law of caste
organisation in Eastern India, that a man’s social status varies in
inverse ratio to the width of his nose, the utmost that can be
predicated is that the average nasal index of a large number of the
members of any caste indicates, in a very uncertain manner, the amount
of aboriginal blood amongst its members, and thereby indirectly the
greater or less respectability of the occupation followed.
[The Cephalic Index. The Mesaticephalic head.] 20. “It appears from the
nasal statistics that not only an occasional Brâhman, but a very
appreciable section of the caste, may be as flat-faced as a Chamâr. It
is also made apparent by Mr. Risley’s measurements of the cephalic
index and of the facial angle that an equally large number are as
round-headed as a Mongoloid Lepcha of the Darjíling Hills, and as
prognathous as any Negritic tribe in Chutia Nâgpur. The following table
is a reproduction of Mr. Risley’s statement of average cephalic
indices:—
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account