Criminals -- Fiction; Social problems -- Fiction; United States -- Social conditions -- 1865-1918 -- Fiction
Having, as he said, indicated the outline of his argument, Ford said
that he would pass to a second proposition; namely, that the motion must
be granted for another reason. In stating this reason, Ford used the
phrases, "trespass" and "contributory negligence," and these phrases had
a sound even more ominous than the phrases "proximate" and "act of God."
Ford declared that the railroad yards were the property of the railroad
company, and therefore not a thoroughfare, and that Koerner, in walking
through them, was a trespasser. The fact that Koerner was in the employ
of the railroad, he said, did not give him the right to enter in and
upon the yards--he had the lawyer’s reckless extravagance in the use of
prepositions, and whenever it was possible used the word "said" in place
of "the"--for the reason that his employment did not necessarily lead
him to said yard and, more than all, when Koerner completed his labors
for the day, his right to remain in and about said premises instantly
ceased. Therefore, he contended, Koerner was a trespasser, and a
trespasser must suffer all the consequences of his trespass. Then Ford
began to use the phrase "contributory negligence." He said that Koerner
had been negligent in continuing in and upon said premises, and besides,
had not used due care in avoiding the ice and snow on and about said
frog; that he had the same means of knowing that the ice was there that
the railroad company had, and hence had assumed whatever risk there was
in passing on and over said ice, and that then and thereby he had been
guilty of contributory negligence; that is, had contributed, by his own
negligence, to his own injury. In fact, it seemed from Ford’s argument
that Koerner had really invited his injury and purposely had the
switch-engine cut off his leg.
"These, in brief, if the Court please," said Ford, who had spoken for an
hour, "are the propositions I wish to place before your Honor." Ford
paused, drew from his pocket a handkerchief, pressed it to his lips,
passed it lightly over his forehead, and laid it on the table. Then he
selected a law-book from the pile and opened it at the page his clerk
had marked with a slip of paper. Sharlow, knowing what he had to expect,
stirred uneasily and glanced at the clock.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account