The Unadjusted Girl, With Cases and Standpoint for Behavior AnalysisThomas, William Isaac
Science
The Unadjusted Girl, With Cases and Standpoint for Behavior Analysis
Thomas, William Isaac
Female juvenile delinquents -- Case studies; Young women
The world has become large, alluring, and confusing. Social evolution
has been so rapid that no agency has been developed in the larger
community of the state for regulating behavior which would replace the
failing influence of the community and correspond completely with
present activities. There is no universally accepted body of doctrines
or practices. The churchman, for example, and the scientist, educator,
or radical leader are so far apart that they cannot talk together. They
are, as the Greeks expressed it, in different “universes of discourse.”
41. Dr. Austin O’Malley writes rather passionately about the control
of births, in the Catholic weekly, “America.” Says Dr. O’Malley:
“The most helpless idiot is as far above a non-existent child as St.
Bridget is above a committee on birth control.” Let us pause over
the idiot and the non-existent child. Must we say that all potential
children should be born? Are we to take a firm stand against
celibacy, which denies to so many possible children the right to be
baptized? And will Dr. O’Malley tell us which is the greater virtue,
to bear children that they may be baptized, or to have no children
for the glory of one’s own soul? This solicitude over the
non-existent child has certain drawbacks. How large a family, in
fact, does Dr. O’Malley desire a woman to bear? May she stop after
the fourteenth infant, or must she say to herself: “There are still
non-existent children, some of them helpless idiots; perhaps I will
bear them that they may be baptized.”[43]
Or, if we should submit any series of behavior problems to a set of men
selected as most competent to give an opinion we should find no such
unanimity as prevailed in a village community. One set of opinions would
be rigoristic and hold that conformity with the existing code is
advisable under all circumstances; another pragmatic, holding that the
code may sometimes be violated. For example, in 1919, the United States
Interdepartmental Social Hygiene Board authorized the Psychological
Laboratory of the Johns Hopkins University to make an investigation of
the “informational and educative effect upon the public of certain
motion-picture films”, and in this connection a questionnaire was sent
to “medical men and women who have had most to do with problems in sex
education and the actual treatment of venereal infections.” From the
manuscript of this investigation I give below some of the replies
received to question 13.
42. _Question 13_. _Do you consider that absolute continence is
always to be insisted upon? Or may it be taught that under certain
conditions intercourse in the unmarried is harmless or beneficial?_
Dr. A. I know of no harm from absolute continence. Intercourse in
the unmarried cannot be justified on any grounds of health or
morals.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account