This same hypothesis immediately makes it possible for all the great
variety of stars in the galactic system to be of approximately the
same age, and so to have been all born out of the same nebula. The
most luminous galactic stars can hardly have been generating energy
at their present rate for more than about 100,000 million years—any
longer age would require an impossibly high weight to start with. Yet
the motions of the stars indicate that even these highly luminous
stars must have been in existence for at least 50 times this period.
The apparent contradiction disappears if we admit that the extreme
luminosity of the very brightest stars may be a recent development, and
that for perhaps 98 per cent. of its life such a star was losing but
little energy because most of its atoms were stripped bare of electrons
and so were immune from annihilation. The requisite proportion of 98
per cent. may seem suspiciously large, but we have stated an extreme
case; we need only demand so large a proportion in the case of a very
rare type of star: probably not more than one star in ten million is of
such a type.
In their earlier dormant state, these stars, which are now so
luminous, would in effect have been white dwarfs of enormous weight.
Observational astronomy provides no evidence that any such stars exist,
but there is certainly no evidence that they do not exist. Very massive
stars are known to be very rare objects, so that in all probability we
should have to travel a long distance from the sun before finding one,
and then it might be so distant as to be invisible from the earth. In
any case, a very distant star of feeble luminosity would be exceedingly
likely to escape detection. We could not infer that no such stars
existed from the fact of none having yet been found.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account