The unseen universe : $b or, physical speculations on a future stateStewart, Balfour
Religion
The unseen universe : $b or, physical speculations on a future state
Stewart, Balfour
Immortality; Religion and science
But, after all, suppose that the every-day experience of men is that
only he who lives in the world as not of the world lives a true life,
and this is the Bible teaching,—whose then is the true doctrine?
Swedenborg errs if he claims this as his _exclusive personal_
experience. Paul claimed it as belonging to all men. Surely men of
science should of all men claim this likewise.
Now, when a man unquestionably honest makes an assertion such as
Swedenborg made, there are only two possible conclusions to which we
can come, unless we choose to remain in a state of mental suspense.
We must either believe that he really saw what he professes to have
seen, or that he was the victim of some strange hallucination, in
virtue of which his subjective impressions became transferred into
the realms of objective realities. We know very well that the human
mind is extremely prone to such delusions, and that the nature
of the case is frequently betrayed by some indiscreet admission
which we have external grounds for believing to be incorrect. Had
Swedenborg confined himself to the invisible world it would have been
very difficult to prove him the subject of a delusion, but when he
converses with angels from the planets, and thus comes to describe
their inhabitants, he enters at once upon dangerous ground.
Concerning his description of the various planets it has been
remarked that his information relates only to those, the existence
of which was known when he wrote, Uranus and Neptune being passed
over. This of itself is a suspicious circumstance. Again, he peoples
the planets Jupiter and Saturn with inhabitants as well as our own
Moon; now, scientific analogy is strongly against either of these two
planets being inhabited, while it is next to certain that our moon
is entirely without inhabitants.
In fine, there is no reason to suppose that the speculations of
Swedenborg were anything else than the product of his own mind, in
the same sense as that in which the speculations of this volume may
be regarded as the product of the minds of its authors.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account