The Valet's Tragedy, and Other StudiesLang, Andrew
History
The Valet's Tragedy, and Other Studies
Lang, Andrew
History; World history
The ‘Journal du Siege d’Orleans’ is in parts a late document, in
parts ‘evidently copied from a journal kept in presence of the actual
events.’* The ‘Journal,’ in February 1429, vaguely says that, ‘about
this time’ our Lord used to appear to a maid, as she was guarding her
flock, or ‘cousant et filant.’ A St. Victor MS. has courant et saillant
(running and jumping), which curiously agrees with Boulainvilliers. The
‘Journal,’ after telling of the Battle of the Herrings (February 12th,
1429), in which the Scots and French were cut up in an attack on an
English convoy, declares that Jeanne ‘knew of it by grace divine,’
and that her vue a distance induced Baudricourt to send her to the
Dauphin.** This was attested by Baudricourt’s letters.***
*Quicherat. In Proces, iv. 95.
**Proces, iv. 125.
***Proces, iv. 125.
All this may have been written as late as 1468, but a vague reference to
an apparition of our Lord rather suggests contemporary hearsay, before
Jeanne came to Orleans. Jeanne never claimed any such visions of our
Lord. The story of the clairvoyance as to the Battle of the Herrings is
also given in the ‘Chronique de la Pucelle.’* M. Quicherat thinks that
the passage is amplified from the ‘Journal du Siege.’ On the other hand,
M. Vallet (de Viriville) attributes with assurance the ‘Chronique de la
Pucelle’ to Cousinot de Montreuil, who was the Dauphin’s secretary at
Poictiers, when the Maid was examined there in April 1429.** If Cousinot
was the author, he certainly did not write his chronicle till long after
date. However, he avers that the story of clairvoyance was current in
the spring of 1429. The dates exactly harmonise; that is to say, between
the day of the battle, February 12th, and the setting forth of the Maid
from Vaucouleurs, there is just time for the bad news from Rouvray to
arrive, confirming her statement, and for a day or two of preparation.
But perhaps, after the arrival of the bad news, Baudricourt may have
sent Jeanne to the King in a kind of despair. Things could not be worse.
If she could do no good, she could do no harm.
*Proces, iv. 206.
**Histoire de Charles VII., ii. 62.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account