The Valet's Tragedy, and Other StudiesLang, Andrew
History
The Valet's Tragedy, and Other Studies
Lang, Andrew
History; World history
In one variant, a clock and a preternatural light are thrown in, with
a sermon which it were superfluous to quote. In another we have the
derangement of clocks and watches. Lord Lyttelton’s stepmother
believed in the dove. Lady Lyttelton did without a dove, but admitted a
fluttering sound.
For causes of death we have--heart disease (a newspaper), breaking of a
blood-vessel (Mason), suicide (Coulton), and ‘a suffocating fit’ (Pitt
Place document). The balance is in favour of a suffocating fit, and is
against suicide. On the whole, if we follow the Pitt Place Anonymous
(writing some time after the event, for he calls Mr. Fortescue ‘Lord
Fortescue’), we may conclude that Lord Lyttelton had been ill for some
time. The making of his will suggests a natural apprehension on his
part, rather than a purpose of suicide. There was a lively impression
of coming death on his mind, but how it was made--whether by a dream, an
hallucination, or what not--there is no good evidence to show.
There is every reason to believe, on the Pitt Place evidence, combined
with the making of his will, that Lord Lyttelton had really, for some
time, suffered from alarming attacks of breathlessness, due to what
cause physicians may conjecture. Any one of these fits, probably, might
cause death, if the obvious precaution of freeing the head and throat
from encumbrances were neglected; and the Pitt Place document asserts
that the frightened valet DID neglect it. Again, that persons under the
strong conviction of approaching death will actually die is proved by
many examples. Even Dr. Hibbert says that ‘no reasonable doubt can be
placed on the authenticity of the narrative’ of Miss Lee’s death, ‘as it
was drawn up by the Bishop of Gloucester’ (Dr. William Nicholson) ‘from
the recital of the young lady’s father,’ Sir Charles Lee. Every one
knows the tale. In a preternatural light, in a midnight chamber, Miss
Lee saw a woman, who proclaimed herself Miss Lee’s dead mother, ‘and
that by twelve o’clock of the day she should be with her.’ So Miss
Lee died in her chair next day, on the stroke of noon, and Dr. Hibbert
rather heartlessly calls this ‘a fortunate circumstance.’
The Rev. Mr. Fison, in ‘Kamilaroi and Kurnai,’ gives, from his own
experience, similar tales of death following alleged ghostly warnings,
among Fijians and Australian blacks. Lord Lyttelton’s uneasiness and
apprehension are conspicuous in all versions; his dreams had long been
troubled, his health had caused him anxiety, the ‘warning’ (whatever
it may have been) clinched the matter, and he died a perfectly natural
death.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account